Basketball

Encinitas’ La Paloma Theater Faces Possible Sale as Surf Community Calls for Preservation

Nov 17, 2026 • 5 min read • views

La Paloma Theater’s value to Encinitas is measured in more than its age. For generations, the venue has connected local audiences through film and live events; for surf culture, it’s also been a stage for premieres that helped define the community’s identity. Talk of a possible sale has put that role in focus. The question is bigger than whether one building keeps its current use: it’s whether a place with a public role can remain part of local life as ownership and plans change.

A surf cinema with local roots

The theater hosts Taylor Steele’s Sessions Surf Festival and screened his Momentum Generation films in the 1990s. A premiere at La Paloma has become a sought-after moment for surfers and filmmakers, linking the venue to a scene that extends well beyond its screen. That connection gives the theater a role that a standard movie venue may not have: it brings filmmakers, athletes and audiences into the same room around work rooted in surf culture. The screen is only part of the draw.

Those events also help explain how a local venue can acquire meaning beyond its immediate neighborhood. A film premiere gives a community a place to encounter its own stories together, while recurring festivals build habits and relationships around the venue. This is more significant than it looks: the loss of that function can be difficult to measure in a building plan, even when residents feel it clearly.

That history makes the reported prospect of a sale especially consequential. A buyer is said to be considering a church and community center for the building, but the plans haven’t been publicly confirmed. The petition circulating among residents says theater personnel reported the possibility; it calls for the venue to remain available for films, concerts and community events. For now, that distinction matters: residents are responding to a reported possibility, not a confirmed transaction or published plan. The uncertainty leaves room for discussion, but it also makes the petition an early attempt to establish what the community hopes will be considered.

View this post on Instagram

Historic recognition as a path to preservation

There’s a practical preservation case alongside the cultural one. Don Miralle, a longtime Encinitas resident and photographer, points to an 83-page Historical Resource Evaluation Report prepared by Dudek in 2016 for Encinitas 101 Mainstreet. The report concluded that La Paloma qualified for designation on both the National Register of Historic Places and the California Historical Landmarks registry. That finding gives preservation advocates a documented starting point, though an evaluation and a formal designation are different steps. The report’s conclusion doesn’t itself establish protected status; it identifies a basis for seeking recognition.

Miralle says the city should follow that evaluation by nominating the theater for state and national landmark recognition. The designation process could give preservation efforts a firmer footing, while the petition asks local officials, historians, preservation advocates and residents to discuss options that address community needs and retain the building’s historic use. If you’re working in this space, the distinction between recognition and a workable plan is familiar: a designation can clarify the building’s importance, while practical decisions still have to address its future use and stewardship.

That said, preservation isn’t only a question of whether a building meets historical criteria. It also involves deciding what continued public use might look like and how different community needs could be heard. The petition’s call for discussion points toward that harder work.

What’s at stake

La Paloma has long served as a gathering place: a cinema, a live-event venue and a site where local memories accumulate across generations. The petition frames its importance in those everyday terms, from family outings to first dates and shared screenings. Its argument is that changing the building’s use would also weaken a rare civic space in a coastal town facing pressure from redevelopment. The case rests on both physical history and repeated use: people return to familiar venues because they offer a shared setting that can’t be replicated by a list of events alone.

That’s the part most people overlook (and this is the part most people overlook): a community venue’s value can be visible in the small routines around it, not just in landmark reports or marquee events. A familiar theater gives residents a common reference point, while its schedule can bring together people who might otherwise have little reason to meet. Losing that role would change how the building participates in local life, even if the structure itself remained standing.

Residents are being asked to sign the petition to raise awareness. Its organizers say the campaign isn’t currently seeking donations. The next test will be whether the city and community can turn the theater’s documented historic value into a preservation plan before any sale or change of use is confirmed. Here’s the thing: public attention can make the issue visible, but it can’t settle questions about a buyer’s plans or the building’s eventual use. The case for keeping La Paloma active will depend on sustained discussion and a clear account of what residents want the venue to continue doing.

What the debate means for Encinitas

The discussion around La Paloma touches a common tension for older venues: a building can carry cultural meaning while its long-term use remains subject to decisions by owners and the community. That tension is especially clear here because the reported possibility is still unconfirmed. Speculation can mobilize residents, but it can also blur the line between a concern and an established plan. Keeping that distinction clear will help the public conversation stay grounded in what’s known.

And yet, uncertainty can be a reason to begin the conversation early. The petition’s requests point toward practical questions: who should be involved, what kinds of events matter to residents, and how historical recognition might inform future choices. No outcome is established by the material available here. For now, the immediate significance lies in whether Encinitas treats La Paloma as a venue with a continuing public role, rather than only as a building whose past can be documented.

A place for films, concerts and community events. That’s the future the petition asks residents to keep in view.

Sign the petition to preserve La Paloma Theater.