Ohio State’s playoff position now hinges on whether its offense can function without Julian Sayin. That’s a striking shift for a program that has never finished below seventh in the College Football Playoff rankings since their introduction in 2014. After a second loss, the Buckeyes are no longer a safe bet to reach the 12-team field. A third defeat would leave them depending on other results, with four difficult games still ahead and no clear timetable for Sayin’s return.
The concern goes beyond replacing a starting quarterback. Ohio State looked like the country’s most dependable elite team in September, on the assumption that early offensive flaws would ease with time. Instead, the backup situation, the running game and the lack of receiving production beyond Jeremiah Smith have become more exposed. The defense has generally done its part, even while allowing 30 points to a strong USC offense. The offense has offered fewer reasons for confidence.
That leaves Ohio State with little margin for error. A three-loss team could still make the playoff in a season shaped by parity in the Big Ten and SEC, but the Buckeyes would no longer control their own path. An 8-4 finish, unthinkable for a team with national championship ambitions, is now within the range of outcomes. The remaining schedule features no great teams, but every opponent has a route to making the game uncomfortable.
The backup quarterback question
The depth chart has not produced the ready-made replacement Ohio State needed. Tavien St. Clair, a 6-foot-5, 235-pound second-year quarterback, arrived as a five-star prospect in 2025 and spent the season behind Sayin. Reports from the spring suggested he had secured the backup role and might develop into the program’s next standout passer. But head coach Ryan Day chose true freshman Luke Fahey as the first quarterback off the bench.
That decision carries extra weight because Ohio State has not turned to St. Clair for specialized opportunities either. Against USC, the Buckeyes had short-yardage situations that appeared suited to a mobile quarterback with his size. St. Clair did not get the call. The coaching staff’s reluctance to use him in those spots raises a practical question: if Fahey struggles, how much can Ohio State count on the player who was passed over?
Fahey may become a capable quarterback, but his USC performance showed how far he has to go to keep the offense on schedule. He completed 10 passes to Smith for 83 yards, while his other teammates combined for 11 catches. He added little as a runner and missed several open targets with high throws, including at least two potential touchdowns. On a late two-point attempt that could have kept the game alive, his pass sailed well beyond its intended destination.
That performance also narrowed the defense’s problem. USC could focus attention on Smith while seeing limited production from the rest of the receiving group. Fahey’s trouble pushing the ball accurately downfield made Ohio State’s most reliable threat easier to anticipate. A backup quarterback doesn’t need to reproduce Sayin’s full output, but the Buckeyes need him to make enough throws that opponents can’t build their entire plan around Smith.
The ground game has not developed
Ohio State’s rushing attack has also failed to make the progress the team could reasonably have expected. The Buckeyes rank 90th nationally in yards per carry, or 94th when sacks are removed from the calculation. Their most effective outings have come against Illinois and Maryland; against the larger fronts of Texas, Indiana and Iowa, they have struggled to generate dependable gains. USC’s much-criticized defensive front also held its own.
Bo Jackson ran for 121 yards on 21 carries against the Trojans, a useful total that doesn’t erase the broader lack of explosive plays. Since Week 1, Ohio State has recorded only three runs of at least 20 yards, one in each of its last three games. Against Power Four opponents, its three such carries tie for 53rd among 67 teams, counting Notre Dame.
There is a precedent for a late-season turnaround. In 2024, Ohio State averaged 3.9 yards per carry in October, then improved to 4.4 in November and 4.9 across December and January. Quinshon Judkins and TreVeyon Henderson became highly productive, and the Buckeyes rushed for 214 yards on 41 attempts in their national title win over an excellent Notre Dame defense. That history makes patience understandable. It doesn’t make this year’s results less concerning: the same kind of growth has yet to appear.
When the run game can’t produce big gains, the passing game needs to supply them. Smith remains a remarkable constant, but the other receivers have combined for only 15 receptions of at least 20 yards. That total would rank 54th in the power conferences. USC limited every other Buckeye to no more than two catches, illustrating what can happen when an opponent can devote its attention to Smith without paying a steep price elsewhere.
Four games with upset potential
Ohio State is favored in each of its remaining games, but the matchups offer little room to coast. Oregon has had a disastrous season, yet it has held five of its eight opponents below 4.3 yards per carry when sacks are excluded. The Ducks also have future NFL talent on the defensive line and enough skill-position ability to threaten the Buckeyes. This looks more like a contest that could stay close than a likely blowout.
Northwestern presents a different risk. Chip Kelly has revived the Wildcats’ offense as play caller, while their defense has struggled to stop the run. If Sayin remains unavailable and the game turns into a shootout, Ohio State may have to prove its offense can keep pace. That would be an unusual position for the Buckeyes, but Fahey’s USC showing makes it difficult to dismiss.
Nebraska’s defensive front could again test Ohio State’s weak point. The Buckeyes are unlikely to find easy rushing yards against the Cornhuskers, and the game will be played in Lincoln. Michigan presents the toughest defensive challenge of the group: its defense has been described as the country’s best, and Ohio State will have to find a way to move the ball against it. The Buckeyes could be reminded of 2024, when a Michigan team with a similar profile won in the Horseshoe.
The playoff picture can still change, and Ohio State’s defense gives it a foundation for competing. But the offense needs more than Smith’s individual excellence: it needs a quarterback who can punish coverage, a running game that can handle strong fronts and enough consistency to survive close games. With four such tests ahead, even one loss could leave the Buckeyes waiting on the selection committee. Two would end the playoff argument. The immediate question is whether the offense can improve before the schedule answers it.