England’s men’s and women’s teams both exited the Rugby League World Cup in the group stage, sharpening questions about the strength of the game in England. For former Great Britain winger Brian Carney, the response should be a funded plan to address long-known weaknesses—not another round of discussion.
From recommendations to a plan
The Rugby Football League has appointed a panel of former Great Britain and England players to discuss the national teams’ future and map out ways to improve the international game. In February, it also published 144 strategic recommendations covering governance, finances and player pathways.
Carney’s concern is that the RFL has yet to show how those recommendations will be carried out. “Rugby League doesn't need another discussion about what is wrong,” he said. “We know what is wrong.” He wants the governing body to explain how it will turn the recommendations into a strategic plan.
He sees the World Cup results as a sign of wider structural problems, including a growing gap between England and southern hemisphere teams. Reviewing the national sides alone, he argued, would address only the symptoms. Better pathways, coaching and academies are among the known needs; the harder question is whether the sport can commit the leadership and resources to address them.
“We're trying to fix a leaky roof by buying more buckets,” Carney said. “The big question is whether we have the leadership, the resources and the determination to put those recommendations sitting in front of us in place.”
Leadership and follow-through
Ian Nolan became RFL chief executive in July after working as a senior executive at Manchester United. He has spoken about growing rugby league’s profile and revenue. Carney said Nolan is still new to the role and should be able to challenge past decisions, while arguing that turning the recommendations into a plan should be central to the job.
Carney also warned that a change at the top shouldn’t reset the clock. “We're very good at strategic reviews, but strategic plans are harder to come by,” he said. The recommendations have been on the RFL’s desk for months, he added, and the latest statement had not made clear that a plan was imminent.
His criticism points to a familiar test for sports leadership: whether reviews lead to decisions, funding and delivery. Carney said the sport has a record of producing recommendations but has repeatedly failed to take the next step.
NRL talks are only a starting point
The RFL is in discussions with the Australian Rugby League Commission, which governs the NRL and NRLW, about potential investment in England’s domestic game. Such support could help Super League grow and attract more attention to both the men’s and women’s competitions.
Carney said any agreement would mark the start of the work, not its completion. Investment and management involvement from the NRL would still leave the RFL and Super League clubs responsible for deciding how to strengthen the sport across the pyramid.
“Improvements will not happen by osmosis,” he said. A link with the NRL alone won’t produce a stronger competition or national teams across England, Ireland, Wales, Scotland and France. “The hard work will begin as soon as that contract agreement is signed.”
Widening the player pool
For Carney, long-term progress depends on properly resourcing international teams and grassroots participation. More investment in player pathways and the base of the game could widen the pool from which elite players emerge, while helping build participation and popularity.
He said rugby league isn’t currently putting enough resources—or apparent commitment—into that effort. The practical measure of the RFL’s response will be whether it can turn its 144 recommendations into funded choices that improve coaching, academies and access to the sport. That work will determine whether England’s World Cup exits prompt lasting change.