Everton leave St James’ Park with a win and a clearer direction
Everton’s 1-0 victory over Newcastle offered David Moyes’ side a valuable league result and sharpened the contrast between the teams’ current form. Thierno Barry scored the only goal in the 49th minute, giving Everton their first away league win of the season and moving them up to seventh. Newcastle slipped to 13th after a fourth defeat in five matches across all competitions.
The result came four days after Everton beat the same opponents 3-1 in the Carabao Cup fourth round. For Newcastle, the repeat defeat brought another flat home performance, boos at half-time and full-time, and a stoppage-time dismissal for substitute Jacob Ramsey. He received two yellow cards within 86 seconds.
Everton’s win was not built on a flood of chances converted. Barry and Harrison Armstrong had both missed promising first-half opportunities, and neither side managed a shot on target before the break. But Everton kept creating openings, and a quick free-kick after half-time exposed Newcastle’s sluggish response.
A quick restart turns into the decisive goal
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall took the free-kick quickly and sent Tyrique George forward. George’s shot slipped beneath goalkeeper Lukas Hornicek, leaving Barry with a simple finish into an unguarded net. Sky Sports commentator Andy Hinchcliffe described Newcastle’s defending as “truly shocking” and the goalkeeping as “terrible”.
Newcastle manager Matthias Jaissle argued that the goal should have been ruled out, saying Barry had used a stray elbow on Fabian Schär during the move. The goal stood, and Everton had the advantage their first-half chances had suggested they might earn.
Barry had already passed up a major opening in the 24th minute, swinging at the ball and missing it completely. Just before the interval, Armstrong was left unmarked to meet Dewsbury-Hall’s pullback, but his first-time effort drifted wide. Those misses kept Newcastle in the match, though the home side offered little to suggest it could take control.
Newcastle’s response arrives late
Anthony Elanga came closest to drawing Newcastle level. In the 66th minute, he tried to steer the ball in at the far post, only for it to strike the post and roll across goal before Everton cleared. The home side then waited until the 85th minute to put its first shot on target.
That effort came from substitute Yoane Wissa, whose first-time finish forced Jordan Pickford into a sharp save. Pickford, a former Sunderland goalkeeper, used an outstretched leg to keep the ball out again five minutes later. Newcastle had finally tested Everton, but the late pressure could not undo the damage of a disjointed display.
Ramsey’s red card in the 98th minute made the finish still harder for Newcastle. The midfielder had come on as a substitute and was dismissed after his second booking in barely a minute and a half. Everton held on to complete a league double over their opponents in the space of four days.
Boos reflect a growing gap between expectations and performance
Former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher said Newcastle’s recent home performances had felt “flat and a little bit boring,” a description he found striking given the aggressive, forward-running style associated with Jaissle’s coaching background in the Red Bull system. Carragher said Newcastle had not shown the front-foot approach or energy needed to involve the crowd.
He also pointed to the demands facing a young squad under a young manager, while warning that expectations among supporters were higher than the team’s current performances. Newcastle have lost four of their last five games in all competitions, and this defeat was their second consecutive loss at home.
Jaissle accepted the reaction from the stands. “After a performance like that, I can understand that,” he told Sky Sports. “That’s a reality, and I am responsible for that.” He said the team had plenty to improve and described the result as a consequence of failing to deliver when it mattered.
The Newcastle manager said his players had been committed to a different approach during the week but had not carried it onto the pitch. In possession, he felt they lacked bravery and played too many long balls. He also said confidence was low among both younger and more experienced players, and that the group would need to address the problem together.
Moyes points to chance creation, with Grealish still unavailable
Moyes praised Everton’s commitment and said the squad was working well despite its limited size. He highlighted the chances the team had made, while acknowledging that Barry needed to turn more of his opportunities into goals. This time, the striker was in the right place to convert the decisive rebound.
Beating Newcastle twice in quick succession mattered to Moyes, particularly because league points could help Everton move closer to the top end of the table. He described the standings as tight and said the team wanted to build on the result.
Jack Grealish remained absent from the Everton squad because of a fitness issue. He had also missed the Carabao Cup match after a breach of club discipline involving a training absence, and the team sheet for this game listed him as “not match fit”. Asked whether Grealish could return, Moyes said, “Of course there is,” but added that he did not yet know if the player would be available for Friday’s home league match against Coventry.
For Everton, the win offers a practical boost: a first away league success of the season and a second straight victory over a direct opponent. Newcastle’s immediate challenge is more basic—restore confidence, turn possession into purposeful attacks, and give supporters a home performance that matches their expectations.