Basketball

Why This Year’s MLB Free-Agent Projections Are Harder to Read

Nov 02, 2026 • 5 min read • views

A free-agent forecast with unusually wide margins

Ben Clemens opened the FanGraphs chat by promising fuller answers about each player on his free-agent list. The central theme emerged quickly: he’s less confident in this year’s projections than in any list he’s made, even after putting substantial work into them. A looming, divisive CBA and what he calls the weakest free-agent class of his time as a baseball writer have made the market hard to read. Clemens expects this class to earn less total money than last year’s, though slightly more per WAR. He’s also generally projecting shorter contracts. That choice matters: estimating deal length is the weakest part of his process, he said, and relies heavily on comparing possible contracts and judging what seems plausible. The projections are uncertain; the method for handling short-term deals is uncertain too. The list’s biggest gap from the market may be Kris Bubic. Clemens thinks his own contract estimate is probably higher than Bubic will receive, but says he couldn’t justify ranking him lower based on the information available to him, setting health concerns aside. At the other end, he sees Randy Arozarena as less of a marquee free agent than the top-five placement he finds on many other lists. He also flagged Matt Boyd, Brandon Woodruff, and Kevin Gausman as pitchers he may have ranked too low. That spread of opinion reflects a class with few obvious anchors. Clemens doubts that the middle of the list will produce the same kind of spending as last year’s deals for Kyle Tucker and Bo Bichette. If teams do overpay, he thinks short contracts with high annual values are the likeliest form. He expects brisk business among the middle tier, partly because clubs tend to spend before a lockout. The most difficult placements included Taira, Sato, and Jeffers. Clemens had Jazz Chisholm in his top 10 throughout, placing him after Seiya Suzuki and ahead of Arozarena, though he struggled to predict Chisholm’s contract. Taira’s role is unsettled, and his pitching style has few close comparisons; Clemens says the player’s age and fastball made him want to rank him higher. Sato is a tougher call. Clemens sees traits in him that he liked in Munetaka Murakami, but he was too optimistic about last year’s NPB class. ZiPS projects Sato as the second-best player in this class, though Clemens cautioned that the projection has wide error bars. He disputes the view that Sato’s profile is plainly weaker than Murakami’s or Kazuma Okamoto’s: both Steamer and ZiPS, he said, are bullish on Sato. Clemens also believes Murakami was underpaid, and that his strong performance in Chicago may have shifted teams’ views. He sees defensive flexibility and the possibility of more contact as part of Sato’s appeal, while acknowledging that the projection remains difficult. A few rankings came down to crowded tiers. Paul Blackburn, fourth among relievers in RA9-WAR this season, missed the top 50 after Emilio Pagán opted out and took the final spot. Clemens said roughly 20 relievers had similar projections, and Blackburn lacked as clear a case as some of the others. He had been on the list for much of the process, near the bottom. Clemens also pushed back on treating Luis Arraez and Gleyber Torres as essentially equal players for 2027. Their projected contracts are relatively close—two years and $38 million for Arraez, versus two years and $28 million for Torres—but he questioned the idea that Torres is likely to slug more. From 2024 through 2026, Torres had a .378 slugging percentage over 1,700 plate appearances; Arraez had a .400 mark over 2,000. The chat opened with lighter housekeeping: a Brewers fan asked whether the site would publish a managerial report card for Pat Murphy. Clemens said Jon Becker and Dan Szymborski had written the American League and National League World Series report cards, respectively; Clemens had skipped both because he was working on the free-agent list. Another reader joked about an omitted “Player X,” and Clemens played along, calling him overrated while teasing that the reader was too low on “Player Y.” Clemens’s candor is useful context for anyone relying on the list. These are informed estimates, but the market’s shape is unusually hard to predict—and the projections themselves carry more uncertainty than he’s comfortable with.

Health risk, contract length and market scarcity

A team declining a seemingly attractive option can tell you something, even when it won’t tell you exactly what. Ben Clemens said FanGraphs had no public information explaining why the Padres might pass on Nick Pivetta’s option. After discussing the case internally, the staff concluded that a rejection would point to health concerns serious enough to leave him off their list. Pivetta had looked fine late in the season, and a two year, $32 million deal might look like an easy call for a No. 2 or 3 starter on performance alone. The missing medical picture is the catch. Sonny Gray presents a different kind of uncertainty. Clemens was comfortable with a salary of $25 million or more for one season, but preferred a pay as you go arrangement over a long commitment. He thought Gray could command one of the highest annual values among pitchers, while doubting Gray would want to stay on a lengthy deal once he stopped pitching well. The risk is plain: Gray could “turn into a pumpkin.” So far, he hasn’t. A contender should still want him in the rotation. The free agent market’s thin supply could also push one player’s price higher than a projection suggests. Clemens picked Arozarena as a possible beneficiary: teams seeking a proven slugger who miss out on Suzuki won’t have many alternatives. He didn’t expect Arozarena to land an unexpectedly rich contract, though. Scarcity matters, he said, but it’s difficult to represent mathematically.

Projections get harder when the rules are unsettled

Clemens didn’t include any players predicted to accept a qualifying offer. The timing of the World Series schedule meant the list wasn’t ready; had the series ended in a sweep, he believed it would have been. He also had less confidence than the year before about which players would receive offers. Given a known list, he thought he would have forecast at least one acceptance. Without it, adding a prediction felt awkward. That uncertainty also made this year’s contract exercise harder to calibrate. Clemens starts with player by player estimates, then checks them against broader expectations for the class. He trusts his view of aggregate spending more than his ability to predict every unusual contract detail, so he asks whether groups such as pitchers are likely to earn at a certain general level. The collective bargaining agreement clouds that picture this time. He didn’t say he’d simply cut every projection by five percent if the total looked too high; the point is to use market wide patterns as a check, not a mechanical adjustment.

Taira’s appeal is the uncertainty

Clemens admitted he doesn’t know whether Taira’s unusual profile is undervalued or whether it will work at all. That’s precisely what makes him compelling. Clemens likes pitchers with uncommon arm angles and release points when they can repeat their mechanics, and compared the anticipation around Taira to watching Murakami: the style itself is an open question, and seeing it play out should be a ride. At 5-foot-8 and 220 pounds, Taira invites comparisons to Bartolo Colon, but Clemens sees a more unusual pitcher: a high velocity four seamer delivered from an exceptionally low release point. He also saw a little “Miz” in him, despite Miz being enormous: an excellent fastball that anchors the approach, secondaries that benefit from its plane and angle, and command that may need to improve. Eric likes Taira’s splitter, a view Clemens trusts, but the fastball is likely to define him. Clemens could imagine Taira with the Brewers, though he said that pairing almost certainly wouldn’t happen.

What the projections leave out

Clemens said he wouldn’t produce report cards for managers who missed the postseason. Part of the problem is deciding how to grade them; more fundamentally, much of their regular season work is hard to see in the available analysis. Keeping players ready, maintaining a shared sense of purpose, and managing depth charts and pitching staffs all matter, even when they don’t show up cleanly in a report card. His favorite postseason moments were more concrete. He enjoyed Brewers and Rays games, with the Brewers’ run carrying a personal connection: his wife is from Milwaukee, and her mother has season tickets. Neither Clemens nor his wife attended the series, but they both did. He singled out Michael King returning on zero days’ rest and Nick Martinez pitching in the World Series, along with the Bauers, Frelick and Passan “bromance,” Pat Murphy teasing Cooper Pratt, and Patrick Bailey pinch hitting for Austin Hedges. A separate free agency question raised the prospect of a lockout wiping out April baseball. Clemens agreed with Meg’s view that if the stoppage dragged on and cost the season’s opening month, one player under discussion might simply retire. That possibility hangs over any projection that assumes a normal season will begin on time.

Thin projections, bigger questions

The free-agent projections are unusually light at the top, Ben Clemens says. More of the best available players signed extensions than usual, while the middle of the list looks much like past versions. That gap matters: a familiar-looking market can still offer less upside when its strongest names are gone. Taira is a good example of the uncertainty teams will have to price. Clemens expects him to end up in relief, though a club that pays the most may first see whether he can start. Taira didn’t start often in NPB, and Clemens thinks his style fits the bullpen better over the long run. Still, he got a chance to start this year, and his next team may give him another one. Clemens’ confidence is limited; he says the projections around Taira carry “huge error bars.”

What a short sample can do to a ranking

Mize’s performance against the Padres pushed him down Clemens’ list. Clemens compares an early September ranking based on instinct with a playoff version informed by projections and deeper statistical review. In the first, he had Mize much higher, partly because he gave too much weight to the pitcher’s first half, improving trajectory, first overall pick pedigree and strong stuff. The playoff version made him reconsider. The caution cuts both ways. Mize’s strong stretch was also a small sample, even if it feels persuasive when he’s pitching well in the moment. That’s the trap: a brief run can look like evidence of a lasting change, then recede once the results turn. Clemens’ two-list method is a useful way to see where first impressions and projections diverge. Milwaukee offered a smaller version of the same tension with Kyle Harrison. The Brewers kept him on the roster for all three series but never used him. Clemens says they had tried him late in the regular season and weren’t encouraged, yet wanted to preserve the upside in case they ran into trouble. They kept winning and building leads, so there was no need to change course. The roster spot went unused.

Payroll rules remain a guessing game

A proposed cap and floor could affect Milwaukee’s spending, but Clemens pushes back on treating that system as settled. The league has proposed a $171 million floor; the questioner floated a figure closer to $150 million and estimated the Brewers might need to add $25 million to $35 million to payroll. Possible routes included bringing back Bauers or extending Contreras, Ashby, Turang, Mize or Henderson. Clemens’ point is that the numbers—and even the structure—are still unknown. A cap and floor might emerge, or the league and players could agree to a hybrid involving a soft floor and shared television revenue. He expects any major change to come with a phase-in period. Without one, the Nationals and Marlins could be asked to roughly double payroll while the Dodgers would need to cut theirs by two-thirds. That makes an immediate effect on this year’s contracts less likely. And if Randy Arozarena reaches the market as a proven slugger, Clemens sees Philadelphia as a plausible destination. He describes Arozarena as something like a next-generation Castellanos. It’s a sharp comparison, though the conversation offers no specific contract forecast.