Fernando Alonso’s criticism of Formula 1’s backmarkers has reopened a familiar debate: do first-lap incidents reflect a lack of driving talent, or the pressures of fighting for limited opportunities? After his collision with Alex Albon at the United States Grand Prix, the Aston Martin driver has stood by his claim that some drivers at the rear of the field show a “very low level” and a “lack of talent.” Albon, Pierre Gasly and Oliver Bearman reject that assessment, arguing that the grid is stronger than Alonso suggests.
Austin collision sets off the dispute
The argument followed an opening-lap clash at Austin. Albon attempted to pass Alonso for 12th place into the Turn 11 hairpin, but his Williams struck the side of Alonso’s Aston Martin. The contact damaged both cars. Neither driver was penalised, and both continued to the finish: Alonso placed 16th, with Albon 17th.
After the race, Alonso said the quality of drivers in the bottom third of the grid was “very low.” He repeated that view during media day ahead of the Mexico City Grand Prix, describing the problem as a matter of driving standards and talent. His criticism extended beyond the Austin incident to what he sees as a pattern of errors and crashes, particularly on the opening lap.
“When you make repeated mistakes throughout the season and have crashes and 50 per cent of your race is in Lap 1, if I was the team principal I would not be happy,” Alonso said. He added that if teams were satisfied with those performances, that was their decision.
His comparison was with leading drivers who can start near the back after an engine change and still fight for victory. Alonso pointed to Max Verstappen and Lewis Hamilton, as well as Kimi at Monza, saying they can afford to wait for a better opportunity rather than force a move immediately. In his view, confidence and talent let a driver recognise that the first lap does not decide the race.
Alonso says the midfield creates its own pressures
Alonso said he did not plan to raise the matter at the drivers’ meeting in Mexico, calling incidents part of racing. He also acknowledged that Aston Martin has a practical way to avoid some of the battles he criticises: start further up the order. He framed the issue as particularly acute for teams with little chance of scoring points, where a race can become a matter of reaching the finish and hoping other cars retire.
“Some teams cannot score points. It’s the same for us this year,” he said. “You go into the races knowing you need eight DNFs to score points, so it’s more about driving the best race to the finish line.”
That context complicates his argument. Alonso suggested poor results, including being beaten by a teammate, can add frustration for drivers, but said other teams and drivers should not bear the cost of it. His comments cast aggressive moves as avoidable mistakes. The drivers who responded offered a different reading: when the top positions are effectively occupied by the leading teams, midfield competitors may feel compelled to take chances to make progress.
Alonso also said that his view of back-of-grid driving would have been the same throughout his career, which began in 2001. He argued that cars at the rear are harder to control because they have less grip and provide a less predictable environment. That, he said, makes errors more likely. But he questioned the need for first-lap contact and damaged front wings when drivers are fighting for little at the bottom of the order, especially given the cost cap and the expense of repairing cars.
He pointed to teams that, in his view, are content to keep repairing cars after repeated damage. The comment links the on-track debate to a concrete team concern: collisions have consequences beyond a driver’s result, because damaged parts must be replaced. Alonso did not suggest a change to the rules; his focus was on whether drivers should take fewer risks when the payoff is limited.
Albon and other drivers push back
Albon was asked about Alonso’s remarks during an FIA press conference. He said he had great respect for Alonso and had looked up to him as a child, but found the comments difficult to hear from a driver he admired. He disagreed with the assessment, saying the standard across the grid is strong.
Albon also challenged Alonso’s comparison with earlier eras. In his view, the back half of the grid 10 or 15 years ago was not as strong as it is now, and he said the current field no longer has pay drivers in the same way. A pay driver is generally understood as someone whose seat is secured mainly through personal financial backing, such as sponsorship or personal wealth that can benefit a team.
Gasly, who races for Alpine, backed Albon’s broader point while acknowledging Alonso’s tendency to speak candidly. Gasly said he had not watched Alonso’s Austin race and could not be certain which incident the Spaniard meant. From his experience over roughly nine years, though, he considers the current field among the strongest he has seen. He recalled seeing more erratic approaches to racing when he first joined F1 than he sees today.
Bearman, a Haas driver, also called Alonso’s conclusion harsh. He agreed with Gasly that the grid is highly competitive and argued that the gaps between teams can make opportunistic moves necessary. Those attempts do not always work: Bearman referred to a collision involving himself and Gasly the previous week as an example of how an effort to make something happen can end badly.
For Bearman, the issue is less about driver quality than the structure of the competition. If the top eight places are usually filled by the four leading teams, drivers elsewhere have fewer straightforward ways to improve their results. Taking a chance may be the only route to a better position, even when the margin for error is small.
The debate follows the drivers to Mexico
The disagreement has no simple resolution in the Austin result. Albon’s move ended in contact, but neither driver was penalised; Alonso’s broader claim rests on a pattern of incidents and mistakes that he says has persisted across the season. Albon and his fellow midfield drivers counter that the field is strong and that the competitive gaps push them toward difficult decisions.
Alonso’s own remarks also point to a tension in his position: he says teams should avoid needless damage, while recognising that teams at the back face long odds of scoring. The drivers taking those risks may see a narrow chance to change the outcome; Alonso sees errors that drivers with greater confidence and talent would avoid. The Mexico City Grand Prix offers the next test of that argument, with Alonso saying he will leave the issue out of the drivers’ meeting and focus instead on getting Aston Martin further up the grid.
The Mexico City Grand Prix is scheduled to follow the United States round. Sky Sports F1 listed practice sessions on Friday, October 30, qualifying on Saturday, October 31, and the race on Sunday, November 1. Its coverage information included a streaming option through NOW.