Football

Brewers Face William Contreras and Trevor Megill Decisions After World Series Win

Oct 29, 2026 • 5 min read • views

Milwaukee’s first World Series title changes the arithmetic of its offseason. The Brewers have built around a relatively modest payroll, moving stars nearing free agency when keeping them would squeeze the roster. Now postseason revenue could give the club more room through 2027, just as it faces decisions on catcher William Contreras, closer Trevor Megill and first baseman Andrew Vaughn.

The choices expose the tension behind Milwaukee’s model: retain key contributors and risk a tighter budget, or convert them into younger talent before their control runs out. Both Contreras and Megill are due to reach free agency after the 2027 season. Their cases differ sharply, though. Contreras is a World Series MVP and a difficult player to replace; Megill is an effective reliever in a bullpen stocked with alternatives.

Contreras has a strong case to stay

Milwaukee holds a $14.5 million club option on Contreras for 2027. He’s coming off a season in which he helped lead the team to its championship, and the projected cost makes picking up the option an easy call. MLB Trade Rumors contributor Matt Swartz estimated that Contreras would earn $14.6 million through arbitration, so the option effectively locks in a comparable salary for next year.

The harder question is what happens after that. Milwaukee could trade him, as it has done with several prominent players entering their final year of club control. But the Brewers don’t have a clear successor ready at catcher. Former top prospect Jeferson Quero struggled in 2026. The club acquired Bo Naylor from Cleveland at the trade deadline, but he’s a gamble: after hitting well as a rookie in 2023, he has produced more with his defense than his bat across 900 major league plate appearances.

Replacing Contreras would mean finding a starting catcher elsewhere, while giving up the reigning World Series MVP. That’s a steep price for a team that has shown it can value leadership and everyday contributions alongside prospect returns. Milwaukee kept Willy Adames for his final season rather than trade him. President of baseball operations Matt Arnold has pointed to Adames’ leadership and his value at a premium defensive position as reasons to keep him. Contreras offers a similar argument.

There’s also precedent for the club turning a departing star into future value without trading him. After keeping Adames through 2024, Milwaukee made him a qualifying offer. His subsequent signing with the Giants earned the Brewers a compensatory first-round selection, which they used on shortstop Brady Ebel, now one of the organization’s seven or eight leading prospects.

A longer deal could keep the catcher in Milwaukee

Milwaukee could try to extend Contreras rather than wait until 2027 to decide whether to trade or retain him. A deal of that scale would likely be only the third nine-figure contract in franchise history, after extensions for Christian Yelich and Ryan Braun.

Jon Heyman of the New York Post reports that Milwaukee made an offer in 2025: three years and $35 million, with a club option for a fourth season. Contreras’ representatives at Octagon reportedly considered it low enough that they didn’t make a counteroffer.

The offer’s value depended on how much of Contreras’ arbitration salary it would cover. He earned $9.4 million this season and is expected to receive $14.5 million next year. Based on those figures, the proposed contract would have bought out one free-agent year for about $11 million. Even if the Brewers expected his final two arbitration seasons to total roughly $22 million, the offer would have priced that additional free-agent year at about $13 million, with a fourth season available to the club.

A new offer could look different. Contreras’ 2027 salary is largely set, so an extension would need to add several seasons beyond it. A high annual value over four additional years might be enough to prompt a conversation; a longer structure could spread the cost. Yelich’s contract runs through 2028, so the commitments would overlap for only one year. If ownership is comfortable with one salary above $20 million, Milwaukee could backload a Contreras deal so his pay rises after Yelich’s contract ends.

Megill’s value may make a trade more attractive

Megill’s situation is less complicated by roster need. He’ll turn 33 in December, making him four years older than Contreras, and Milwaukee has considerable bullpen depth. Aaron Ashby could move into the closer role after his postseason performance. Abner Uribe, DL Hall and Grant Anderson are also set to return.

Megill’s 2026 performance should draw interest from contenders. He posted a 2.63 ERA over 61 2/3 innings, struck out 28.5% of hitters and walked 6.2%. Swartz projects an $8 million salary. For clubs seeking late-inning relief, that price could be manageable, giving Milwaukee a chance to acquire a notable prospect or a younger pitcher with more years of team control.

The Brewers have developed an unusually strong record of finding useful bullpen arms, and Megill’s own path illustrates the point: Milwaukee acquired him for a player to be named later after multiple teams had designated him for assignment. That depth makes trading him less disruptive than moving Contreras.

There’s also a difference in potential return if either player leaves. Under the current qualifying-offer system, Contreras could bring Milwaukee compensation if he departs as a free agent. Megill is less likely to qualify for that offer, meaning a trade could be the club’s clearest route to a return. Whether that system continues under a new collective bargaining agreement is unknown.

Vaughn adds a smaller payroll decision

Vaughn gives Milwaukee another choice as it builds a roster around its returning championship core. He appeared part time in 2026, batting .306/.390/.444 in 331 plate appearances. He hit especially well against left-handed pitching, with a .336/.421/.517 line, while producing closer to average results against right-handers. Swartz projects his arbitration salary at $8.5 million.

The Brewers typically don’t commit much money to first base. Vaughn could take on a regular role, but the club could also trade him or decline to tender him a contract and redirect that salary toward a cheaper option. The decision will depend on how Milwaukee values his performance against lefties and whether it sees a better use for the money.

A new financial cushion, familiar choices

The Brewers’ approach has relied on long-term commitments to selected young players and difficult calls on stars nearing free agency. They extended Yelich in March 2020, then secured Jackson Chourio, Ashby, Cooper Pratt and Luis Lara before they had made their major league debuts. Chourio, Pratt and Lara had yet to record a big league plate appearance when they signed deals guaranteeing $82 million, $50.75 million and $31 million, respectively.

At the same time, Milwaukee has traded Josh Hader, Corbin Burnes, Devin Williams and Freddy Peralta with one year of club control remaining, or slightly more in Hader’s case. Earlier examples include Jonathan Lucroy.

Contreras himself arrived through that cycle. Milwaukee acquired Esteury Ruiz in the Hader trade and later sent Ruiz to Oakland in a three-team deal that brought Contreras over from Atlanta. The Hader return also included left-handed pitching prospect Robert Gasser, who contributed to this season’s championship.

Andy McCullough and Will Sammon of The Athletic reported that Milwaukee expects postseason revenue to provide more operating room in the near term, including through 2027. The championship therefore gives the front office a chance to retain more of the roster that delivered it. How much that changes the Brewers’ usual calculus will become clearest in the decisions on Contreras, Megill and Vaughn.

Those choices also carry different costs: Contreras is central to a roster with no obvious catching replacement, Megill has trade value behind a deep bullpen, and Vaughn’s salary could be redirected if Milwaukee finds another first-base fit. The title has bought the Brewers more options. Their challenge is deciding which pieces are worth building around for the next run.