Football

UCF Stuns No. 2 BYU in Double Overtime After Wild Officiating Sequence

Oct 24, 2026 • 5 min read • views

UCF’s 39-31 double-overtime win over No. 2 BYU will be remembered as much for the sequence of decisions and rulings around the end of regulation as for the final goal-line stand. The unranked Knights earned the first AP Top 5 victory in program history, ending BYU’s undefeated run a week after the Cougars’ controversial win over Notre Dame. The finish was a string of reversals, missed chances and one major officiating question.

The game’s defining swing began with UCF in position to take a late lead. It ended with the Knights celebrating after stopping BYU on fourth-and-goal in the second overtime. Between those moments, Scott Frost’s fourth-down call, a blocked kick, a penalty and an incorrect 10-second runoff all shaped the route to the result.

UCF passes on a short field goal

With the score tied 24-24 and less than two minutes left, UCF faced fourth down near the goal line. A short field goal would have put the Knights ahead 27-24. Head coach Scott Frost instead kept the offense on the field, a choice that could have left BYU needing a touchdown or forced the Cougars to start backed up near their own goal line if UCF failed.

UCF did fail. Quarterback Keyone Jenkins was stopped just short on a sneak, turning a seven-minute drive into no points. The call gave BYU the ball and a chance to take control, but the Cougars went three-and-out. Their decision to run on third-and-6, while UCF still had two timeouts, stood out as they prepared to punt the ball back.

That punt set up the sequence that nearly decided the game before overtime. A sack appeared to give BYU possession, but replay review showed Jenkins had thrown an incomplete pass while under pressure. Officials overturned the fumble ruling, then assessed BYU’s Keanu Tanuvasa for unsportsmanlike conduct after he shoved UCF lineman Brady Wayburn’s helmet back toward the turf.

The 15-yard penalty gave UCF field-goal range. Had the fumble call stood, BYU would have had the ball; instead, the Knights had a chance to win. There was no intentional-grounding penalty on Jenkins.

A blocked kick and a clock ruling send the game to overtime

UCF used a spike and a throwaway before kicker Will Stone tried a 46-yard field goal with 11 seconds remaining. BYU blocked the attempt. The ball bounced back to Stone, who ran forward several yards before his helmet came off. Officials first flagged a face-mask penalty that would have given UCF another chance, then picked up the flag and ruled that no foul had occurred.

The missed kick did not necessarily end UCF’s opportunity. Stone had kicked on third down, and the ball had not crossed the line of scrimmage before he recovered and advanced it. Under that sequence, UCF should have been allowed to try again on fourth down.

Instead, officials applied a 10-second runoff because Stone’s helmet had come off. With no timeouts remaining and fewer than two minutes on the clock, the runoff ended the chance to kick again and sent the game to overtime. But rules analyst Terry McAulay later said the runoff should not have been charged: the clock had also stopped because the play was the end of a legal kick down. UCF should have had another field-goal attempt, with the clock starting on the snap.

That postgame assessment made the final seconds even harder to parse. UCF had reached a potential game-winning kick, and the sequence of a blocked attempt, the helmet ruling and the runoff took that chance off the board. The Knights had to win in overtime instead.

Quarterbacks trade touchdowns in the first overtime

BYU struck first in overtime when quarterback Bear Bachmeier found Legend Glasker on third-and-13. The conversion put pressure on UCF to answer, and Jenkins did so immediately. He threw to Josh Derry while moving on the run, tying the score with a touchdown on UCF’s first play of the possession.

The exchange sent the game to a second overtime and kept both teams’ offenses in the spotlight. Bachmeier had created the opening with a difficult third-down throw; Jenkins matched it with a quick, improvised response.

A roughing call gives UCF another chance

UCF began the second overtime on offense and stalled at BYU’s 8-yard line. Stone made the field goal that would have put the Knights ahead, but BYU was called for roughing the kicker. Kendal Wall bowled into a UCF offensive lineman, and both players fell into Stone as the kick passed through the uprights. The flag gave UCF a new set of downs at first-and-goal.

The call was contentious, and it proved pivotal. Jenkins threw a touchdown to Grayson Brousseau, a Utah native who had recorded only one catch before that game—and this became his second catch and second touchdown of the season. UCF then went for two. Jenkins connected with Tyren Hornes on a sliding catch to make it 39-31.

BYU now needed an eight-point score of its own to extend the game into a third overtime, which would have begun with a two-point conversion shootout. Bachmeier scrambled from the 8-yard line to the 4 on first-and-goal. He then threw three straight incompletions, with the final pass falling short of Walker Lyons on fourth down.

The final stop seals UCF’s first Top 5 win

The finish was blunt after a night full of complications: BYU needed to score, and UCF’s defense needed one stop. Bachmeier’s last pass skipped short of Lyons, with no flag to extend the possession. The Knights had held on, 39-31, and BYU’s undefeated season was over.

UCF’s win stands out in a season already marked by a steady run of AP Top 10 upsets. The unusual ending will draw attention to the late-game officiating, especially McAulay’s view that the 10-second runoff was wrongly applied. But the result also reflects the Knights’ ability to recover after passing up a late field goal, then match BYU’s touchdown in overtime and finish with a defensive stand.

For BYU, the loss ends a rapid rise to No. 2 that followed its win over Notre Dame. For UCF, it’s a program milestone earned in a game that repeatedly offered the other team a way back. The next conversation will be about the rulings at the end of regulation; the lasting takeaway is that the Knights made the final play that mattered.