Colson Montgomery’s 2026 season showed why the White Sox can value him as a regular and still have questions about his future. He hit 31 home runs and played strong defense at shortstop, yet struck out more often than any other qualified major leaguer. His power kept the overall package useful; whether it can carry him through another season of such frequent misses is the bigger question.
Power and defense offset a difficult year at the plate
Montgomery appeared in 153 games, with 638 plate appearances. His 31 homers, 87 RBIs and .206 isolated slugging percentage led American League shortstops. On defense, he recorded 10 Outs Above Average at shortstop and ranked in the 94th percentile in Fielding Run Value, according to Statcast. FanGraphs credited him with 2.8 wins above replacement, around the middle of the pack among qualified shortstops.
The rest of his offensive line was far less convincing: .197/.282/.403, with a 91 wRC+. He struck out in 35.6% of his plate appearances, the highest rate among qualified hitters at any position. Teammate Munetaka Murakami was next at 35.4%, but his 16.6% walk rate helped lift his on-base percentage to .347 and his wRC+ to 129. Montgomery walked 8.5% of the time and reached base less than 30% of the time.
That gap matters because home-run power can’t always compensate for weak contact and limited opportunities to get on base. Montgomery’s 2026 production still added up to a useful season, but the margin for error in his offensive profile looks thin.
The gap from his debut points to the key adjustment
Montgomery’s 2025 debut offered a more balanced version of the same power-driven hitter. In 284 plate appearances, he batted .239/.311/.529 with a 130 wRC+ and 21 home runs. His 29.2% strikeout rate was still high, but 6.4 percentage points lower than in 2026. He also delivered strong defense, with seven Defensive Runs Saved and six Outs Above Average at shortstop. FanGraphs valued that half-season at 2.7 WAR.
His swing decisions moved in the wrong direction the following year. Montgomery’s chase rate rose from 30.5% to 32.4%, putting him in the 32nd percentile, and he made contact less often when chasing. FanGraphs’ chase-swing rate climbed from 19.8% to 28.4%. He also swung at “waste” pitches 9.2% of the time, up from 3.8% in 2025. Pitchers challenged him in the strike zone less frequently, and he expanded his own zone in response.
Four-seam fastballs were another clear problem. Montgomery had been worth two runs against the pitch in 2025; in 2026, his run value dropped to minus 13. He hit .154 against four-seamers, with an 11.2% increase in strikeout rate, an 8.7% fall in hard-hit rate and a 200-point drop in slugging percentage. Since he saw four-seamers more than 20% more often than any other pitch, handling velocity will be central to rebuilding his results.
Chicago has time, but its roster picture will change
Montgomery’s profile invites comparison with Joey Gallo: substantial power, many strikeouts and little margin if the home runs fade. Montgomery walks less often than Gallo did, though, and is a better defender at his position. A return toward his 2025 contact and production would make the comparison less concerning. Chicago also has time to assess him: he won’t reach arbitration until 2029 and likely won’t earn more than $5 million until 2030 at the earliest.
A trade for starting pitching is one possibility raised by MLBTR’s Anthony Franco in the site’s offseason outlook. Chicago’s rotation options include Sean Burke, Davis Martin and Anthony Kay. The club acquired Luis Castillo at the trade deadline, but he struggled over 31 innings; he remains under contract for 2027. The White Sox still need more reliable rotation depth to support another postseason push.
There’s also a longer-term question at shortstop. Chicago selected Roch Cholowsky first overall in this year’s draft, and he could reach the majors in late 2027. Montgomery may have most of the next season to establish himself, but Cholowsky is viewed as an excellent fielder and could eventually take over at the position. For Montgomery, the path to a lasting everyday role runs through better swing decisions and a more effective answer to fastballs.
Photo courtesy of Matt Marton, Imagn Images