Football

Rams’ Myles Garrett Trade Faces New Questions as Injuries Mount

Oct 20, 2026 • 5 min read • views
(Photo by Erick W. Rasco/Sports Illustrated via Getty Images/Getty Images)

The Rams’ Myles Garrett trade has become a test of roster depth and medical judgment far sooner than Los Angeles expected. At 2-4, in last place in the NFC West, the team is already making the deal look riskier for Cleveland than it did when the Rams assembled what seemed to be a Super Bowl contender.

That doesn’t make the trade a settled failure. Los Angeles still has Matthew Stafford and Sean McVay, and this isn’t the franchise’s first all-in push. The Rams went for it in 2021 and won the Super Bowl. That history matters: a team that has already reached its goal within the past five years doesn’t fit neatly into the familiar story of a desperate contender mortgaging its future and coming up empty.

But the Browns have a strong early case for feeling good about the return. They received a first-, second- and third-round pick, along with edge rusher Jared Verse, for a 30-year-old Garrett. Cleveland is 4-2, while Garrett is dealing with a knee problem that could sideline him for close to half the season or longer, according to a report on his injury. For now, Cleveland’s decision to sell high looks shrewd.

Verse’s value will take time to judge

Verse is an important part of that return, though his early results in Cleveland haven’t made the trade look lopsided on the field. He has yet to record a sack this season. Some Browns fans who study game footage argue that his play is better than the numbers suggest, as seen in one social media breakdown, but the production will need to arrive. Getting after the quarterback is central to his job.

There’s reason not to overreact to a quiet start. Verse was good enough in Los Angeles to win Defensive Rookie of the Year, and his longer-term value could prove to be the defining piece of the deal for Cleveland. Six weeks of uneven results can’t settle that question. For the Rams, though, his absence leaves another hole in a defense that was supposed to improve with Garrett’s arrival.

A difficult week exposed the Rams’ thin margins

Los Angeles’ loss to Arizona in Week 6 made the team’s current predicament harder to dismiss. The Rams gave up no touchdowns and scored two of their own, but still lost 18-16 after new kicker Blake Grupe tore his ACL while trying to tackle a kickoff returner. Without him, the Rams couldn’t attempt field goals for much of the game. Cardinals kicker Chad Ryland made all six of his field-goal attempts.

The Rams also lost Davante Adams to a hamstring injury late in the game. He’s expected to miss six to 10 weeks, leaving an offense short one of its two dependable receivers. Garrett is out, and defensive linemen Kobie Turner and Poona Ford have also missed extended time. Those absences have turned a roster that looked deep in the offseason into one with little room for more setbacks.

There’s a reason the Rams were widely treated as contenders: the trade for Garrett and the addition of Adams suggested a team willing to spend to win now. Yet the season has brought a string of losses that seem to come from a different source each week. The Cardinals game combined a special-teams injury, a costly absence at kicker and a late injury to a starting receiver. It’s hard to plan around every bad break, but a contender still needs enough depth to absorb some of them.

The draft choice and playoff picture are back in focus

The Rams’ position also changes how their draft decisions look. They selected a quarterback with the 13th pick last year, a move that made sense as a bet on the future but carries a higher opportunity cost if the present roster can’t compete. An offensive lineman, defensive back or receiver might have helped address needs on a team now short-handed at several positions. That’s hindsight, but this season has made the question less theoretical.

Because the trade sent a first-round pick to Cleveland, Los Angeles’ record affects the value of the Browns’ return. The Rams aren’t likely to collapse all the way to a 4-13 finish, but their current performance has made a high pick more plausible than it appeared a few weeks ago. Even a modest slide could leave Cleveland with a valuable selection.

The schedule offers opportunities to recover, including games against the Raiders, Chargers, Commanders and Cardinals. Still, the Rams have already lost to the Broncos and Cardinals, and they’re 0-2 against the NFC West. Three games against the Seahawks and 49ers remain. Those matchups now carry real weight: Los Angeles needs wins against division rivals to keep the playoff race from turning into an increasingly steep climb.

Garrett’s return is the hinge

The trade’s ultimate judgment depends heavily on what Garrett can do when he returns. If he helps turn a struggling defense into a competitive unit, Los Angeles may still get the impact it paid for. If his knee keeps him out for a large portion of the season, the Rams will have given up significant draft capital for limited help at a time when they’re already short on healthy players.

The way the injury was handled raises questions, too. In training camp, the Rams described Garrett’s condition as “soreness,” as Yahoo Sports reported. He then played roughly half of Week 1 while appearing hurt before going on injured reserve for knee surgery. The sequence invites scrutiny of how much the team knew before making the deal and whether it managed the problem well during the preseason.

There’s no need to declare Cleveland the winner after six weeks. Verse’s production can change, the Rams can steady themselves, and Garrett may return with enough time to shape their season. But Los Angeles has already shown how little cushion it has when injuries hit. Its next task is straightforward: stop turning avoidable setbacks into losses, then give Garrett a team still worth returning to.