Matt Donohue is returning to Premier League VAR duty after a high profile error in the Manchester derby. He will serve as assistant VAR when Coventry host Fulham on Saturday, following weeks away from the league’s matchday officiating roster.
The September 13 incident centered on Erling Haaland’s goal for Manchester City at Old Trafford. VAR Donohue and assistant Blake Antrobus judged that the goal should stand, overlooking the effect of City midfielder Enzo Fernandez’s offside position on Manchester United defender Lisandro Martinez.
What the officials missed
The sequence began with an on-field offside decision against Haaland in the 59th minute. City were playing with 10 men when he turned in a cross, but semi-automated offside technology showed that Haaland was onside. That settled one part of the review, but the officials still needed to assess the full attacking move.
Fernandez was also in an offside position as he moved toward the same cross. He did not touch the ball, and the VAR team treated that as decisive. The rules, however, also require officials to consider whether an offside player affected an opponent’s ability to play the ball. Fernandez’s movement appeared to influence Martinez’s defending, which meant the goal should have been disallowed.
The Premier League Match Centre’s explanation on X said VAR had confirmed Haaland was onside and judged that Fernandez “didn’t play the ball.” That account captured the narrow focus of the review: the check established Haaland’s position and Fernandez’s lack of contact, but did not properly assess the defender’s reaction.
Donohue returns after EFL assignments
Donohue had not worked in any of the three Premier League match rounds since the derby. He continued refereeing in the English Football League, taking charge of Derby against Wrexham on October 10 and Southampton against Bolton the following weekend. Saturday’s appointment places him back in the Premier League, this time as assistant VAR.
Antrobus’s return came earlier. He served as an assistant referee for Newcastle’s home match against Aston Villa last Saturday, his first appearance since the derby. The separate return dates put the focus on Donohue’s role in the video review and on how match officials are assigned after a consequential mistake.
Pro Ref acknowledged the error
Hours after Manchester City’s win, Pro Ref said it had contacted Manchester United to acknowledge an “error of judgment.” The organization said Donohue should have recommended an on-field review of the goal. Its statement explained that the original offside call against Haaland was checked and overturned after he was found to be onside. Fernandez’s involvement, it said, made the remaining decision subjective because he had not played the ball.
“The VAR did not recognise the likely impact of his position and should have recommended an on-field review,” Pro Ref said. It also said the incident would be reviewed.
Howard Webb, Pro Ref’s chief refereeing officer, later described the review as a case of “tunnel vision.” On Match Officials Mic'd Up, he said the VAR became focused on Haaland’s position, found him onside by three centimetres and then failed to judge Fernandez’s impact across the full attacking possession phase.
Webb said the rest of the officiating team should have helped redirect the review. “In that moment, he gets tunnel vision but it is down to the rest of his team to pull him out of that tunnel but unfortunately, that did not happen on this occasion,” he said. “This goal should have been disallowed.”
The review audio shows how the check narrowed
The released exchange illustrates the decision process. The assistant referee initially called Haaland offside. Donohue then confirmed that Haaland was onside and said he needed to check the full attacking possession phase, including whether Iliman Ndiaye was onside earlier in the move.
After that check, the VAR returned to Fernandez. The audio records Donohue confirming there was no touch and concluding, “Goal.” He then told the referee to change the decision, saying Haaland was onside and the final decision was a goal. The review did not include a clear assessment of whether Fernandez’s attempt to reach the cross affected Martinez.
That distinction matters. The technology answered whether Haaland was in an offside position; it could not resolve the separate, judgment-based question about Fernandez’s influence on an opponent. The review depended on officials recognizing that the two issues required different assessments.
Criticism focused on Fernandez’s effect on Martinez
Former players and Sky Sports pundits criticized the decision on the basis that Fernandez’s movement disrupted United’s defending. Gary Neville said he expected Pro Ref to apologize publicly and argued that Fernandez was attempting to play the ball and putting Martinez off. Jamie Carragher also said the officials had become too focused on Haaland’s onside position to examine Fernandez’s role closely enough.
Micah Richards said Fernandez was interfering with play and connected the call to another disputed decision in the same derby, involving Phil Foden. Roy Keane argued that United had been punished for holding a good defensive line because Fernandez was offside and moved toward the ball.
The return appointment gives Donohue another Premier League assignment, while Webb’s account identifies the review’s central failure: establishing Haaland’s onside position was only the first step. The match officials also needed to judge what Fernandez’s movement meant for Martinez, and that assessment should determine whether the next review includes an on-field check.