Football

Manchester United’s Como Defeat Exposes a Rift Over Tactics and Effort

Oct 21, 2026 • 5 min read • views

Fernandes challenges the pressing plan

Manchester United’s 4-1 defeat to Como exposed a split in the club’s post-match diagnosis. Captain Bruno Fernandes questioned the coaching staff’s pressing plan; Michael Carrick challenged the players’ effort and intensity. With United winless in seven matches across all competitions, the disagreement points to a problem the team can’t solve with tactics alone. The distinction matters: one account focuses on the choices made before and during the match, while the other asks whether the players carried out their work with enough urgency. Both can be true, and the team has to address both if it’s to change the pattern.

Fernandes challenges the pressing plan

Fernandes said United’s decision to sit off Como and leave space behind the press gave the Italian side too much time to settle into possession. Como completed 594 passes, the most by an opponent in a Champions League match against United since Barcelona made 725 in April 2019. Passing totals don’t explain a result by themselves, but they help show the kind of match United allowed to develop: Como had extended periods on the ball, while United had to decide when and how to close them down. If you're working in this space, the tactical question is whether the plan made it easier for Como to play through the pressure than United expected.

“It's a decision from the staff to not press man-to-man and sometimes leave a little space in behind and try to get the ball in the first moment, to wait for them, to give them the ball,” Fernandes told TNT Sports.

His concern was that allowing Como to keep the ball helped them grow in confidence and forced United to expend energy chasing. When United did regain possession, he argued, tired legs and frustration made it harder to build an attack. That describes a familiar trade-off in pressing: a team can preserve its shape and wait for an opening, but the opponent may use the time to find its rhythm. United’s problem, in Fernandes’ telling, was that the wait didn’t produce enough disruption to justify the cost.

Fernandes said United should have pressed higher and taken more risks to disrupt Como. Asked whether the plan had cost them, he put responsibility on the manager and coaching staff: “That's on the manager and on the staff to see it, it's not on me.” That’s a pointed way for a captain to frame a defeat. It also puts the coaching staff’s decisions in public view, though a single player’s account can’t establish whether the plan was the only cause of the result. The players still have to execute the approach they’re given—and respond when it isn’t working.

It was another public challenge from within the squad after Lisandro Martinez criticised the club hierarchy following United’s previous Champions League defeat, at Atletico Madrid. Martinez had singled out technical director Jason Wilcox over the transfer window. Carrick later met with Martinez and Wilcox, and relations were repaired. The episode gives Fernandes’ criticism added weight as a sign of strain inside the club, but it doesn’t prove that the earlier dispute and this defeat share a cause. It does make the management of disagreements part of the story: United need criticism to lead to better decisions rather than another public fault line.

Carrick points to intensity

Carrick rejected the idea that the pressing approach explained the result on its own. United pressed man-to-man for part of the second half, he said, but still conceded. His central criticism was simpler: “Whatever tactics you play, if you don't run back, you ain't going to win.” The point is not that the plan was beyond question; it’s that the plan can’t account for every failure to track back or compete for the ball. A tactical adjustment may change where the work happens, but it can’t replace the work itself.

The manager said he was “really angry” and called United’s performance unacceptable. He said he would review the coaching decisions, while also questioning whether his players had brought the motivation, purpose and intensity the match demanded. That willingness to review the staff’s choices matters, because it keeps the tactical criticism on the table. At the same time, Carrick’s public message puts responsibility on the squad to meet the basic demands of a match, even after an early setback. Here's the thing: changing the plan only helps if players carry it out with conviction.

United became the first English team to concede within the opening two minutes of consecutive major European matches: Martinez’s side allowed a goal after 47 seconds against Atletico, then after 118 seconds against Como. Those starts gave United little room to settle into either game, but they don’t tell the whole story of the performances that followed. For Carrick, the manner of the performance mattered as much as those early setbacks. A team can concede early and still show a clear response; his concern was that United didn’t do enough to make the rest of the match look different.

“It wasn't just the goals. It was the manner we went about that was the difficult thing to watch,” he said. Carrick apologised to the travelling supporters and added that players can’t choose when to give their full effort. That message sets a straightforward standard, but meeting it requires more than an angry response in a press conference. The players have to show that intensity across the match, and the staff have to give them an approach they can follow when the opponent has the ball. The numbers here are underwhelming. The larger concern is whether the team can turn criticism into a visible change.

United need a response

The defeat leaves United with two losses in three Champions League games and extends their winless run to seven. Fernandes’ comments raise questions about whether the team’s approach out of possession is working; Carrick’s response raises a more basic one about whether the players are carrying it out with enough commitment. The disagreement gives the club two areas to examine: how it wants to press, and whether the squad is prepared to sustain the effort that any pressing plan requires. Neither question can be answered by pointing to the other.

United face Bournemouth at home on Sunday, live on Sky Sports. The immediate test is whether the team can turn the criticism into a performance with more purpose, rather than simply offering a new explanation for the latest result. That said, one match won’t settle every concern raised by a seven-game winless run. What this means for you as a viewer is that the response will be judged in two ways: by whether United disrupt opponents more effectively and by whether the players keep working when the plan or the match turns against them. Shared responsibility. Coaches and players will have to turn their competing diagnoses into a workable plan.