Basketball

How Scouting Context and Video Shape Baseball Prospect Evaluations

Oct 20, 2026 • 5 min read • views

What steady farm systems get right

Brendan Gawlowski opened the FanGraphs chat by pointing to the Rays and Brewers as examples of organizations where scouting, player development and front office work reinforce one another. Their sustained success, he argued, shows why evaluating players in isolation misses part of the picture: the fit between the people and systems around a player matters too. That same judgment runs through his prospect answers. Asked which of Leo Bernal, Vahn Lackey and Nathan Flewelling was likeliest to become a solid major league catcher, Gawlowski picked Lackey while saying he liked all three. Charles Davalan’s chances at second base looked promising, he said, though the young player still needs repetitions; he has the athleticism and range to handle the position.

What changes an evaluation

Prospect grades can shift during the offseason even when there hasn’t been a new live look. Gawlowski initially misunderstood a question about how that happens, then explained that a year’s worth of video and data gives evaluators plenty to review. A player who appears unchanged may have added a pitch, for example, and a fresh look at the video can reveal whether it works. Sometimes that review confirms the existing view. Sometimes it doesn’t. Gawlowski said he wished he’d been more cautious about Kade Anderson in the midseason update; after seeing Anderson’s four-seam fastball with the major league ball, he expects to lower the pitch’s grade.

The limits of scouting from a screen

Speed grades offer a good example of why a number can’t capture every useful observation. Gawlowski uses home-to-first time as his starting point, then may adjust the grade by half a point based on how playable the speed looks. Being at the ballpark helps him judge a runner’s first step on the bases or in the field, while video feeds can distort running times when camera angles aren’t synchronized. He recalled a scout who got into trouble after assigning 60 run grades to 30 runners based on video with mismatched camera angles. It’s a pointed reminder: even a measurable tool can produce bad results when the footage is wrong. Catcher framing presents a similar trade-off. Gawlowski finds it easier to judge on video, where he can focus on the catcher instead of everything happening around the field. He looks for mobility, a low stance, a strong wrist and limited head movement. Technique can improve, he said, if the physical tools are there. Nathan Flewelling, in particular, stays low and can funnel pitches toward the plate from different directions.

Small adjustments, uncertain forecasts

Some evaluations turn on details that are still hard to interpret. Gawlowski saw enough velocity separation between Jarlin Susana’s slowest and fastest breaking balls to treat them as two pitches, though Susana may simply have been varying the speed of one pitch. Either way, Gawlowski liked that he could change the look. On Arjun Nimmala, he said the overall evaluation was holding steady, perhaps a tick lower. He wasn’t ready to move Nimmala off shortstop, though each viewing made that outcome seem a little more plausible. For the Dodgers’ next homegrown starting pitcher, Gawlowski named Zazueta as the current front-runner. Other questions drew answers with less certainty. Los Angeles Angels sources, he said, planned to try Jared Grimdlinger as a two-way player, a route that could slow his progress but would be exciting to watch. Looking back at an old report that gave Jurickson Profar a 70 present grade for shortstop defense, Gawlowski said injuries may have played a part, but the grade may also have been too generous. He added that he was a novice at the time. Asked whether Mickey Moniak had looked less athletic when he first arrived at camp after being drafted first overall, Gawlowski said he hadn’t seen him then. Moniak still playing some center field in major league games ten years after the draft, he said, suggests athleticism wasn’t necessarily the problem.

Planning around an uncertain season

For fans weighing a spring training trip against the Cape Cod League or the Arizona Fall League, Gawlowski had no firm forecast about whether games would be played in late February. He guessed the situation might resemble 2022, possibly with some missed games, while admitting the outlook was difficult to call. Minor league players’ contract status was part of the fan’s question, but Gawlowski didn’t address it directly. His practical advice was to wait if possible: booking only a few weeks ahead could mean better hotel deals, and crowds at major league games might be light. Fans content to watch on backfields, he added, could go ahead and make plans. At 11:03 a.m., Gawlowski welcomed everyone and got started. The chat excerpt ends as he begins responding to a question about Orioles prospects in the Fall League, so it doesn’t include his answer.

Prospect grades and player development

The evaluations here are deliberately provisional. A player can show one tool clearly while leaving major questions unanswered, and a prospect’s timeline is often harder to pin down than his talent.

Brendan Gawlowski was pleasantly surprised by Honeycutt: he looked capable at the plate, even if the impact seemed closer to a 40-grade player than a major standout.

Petey Bienel asked whether Cayden Wallace had done enough to regain the 40 grade he held in the Kansas City system. Gawlowski thought that sounded about right, though he’d want to assess Wallace’s defense before settling on a grade. Wallace has reached the AA power grade Gawlowski had assigned him, but his approach remains a problem.

Asked where Ace Reese might end up defensively, Gawlowski named first base or left field.

StuShea wondered whether the White Sox should hold Colson Montgomery for another year, and whether he could improve. Gawlowski said yes: Montgomery’s numbers fell sharply around the time he was hurt, and he believes Montgomery was playing through something in the second half.

Rayball asked for a season review of Josiah Ragsdale. Gawlowski said it was much like the midseason assessment, available in the Trade Deadline Prospects Guide to the Milwaukee Brewers.

On David Hagaman, Gawlowski put the ceiling at a No. 3 starter and expected a 45 grade this winter, with a chance at 45+. Hagaman could reach the desert next year; Gawlowski gave either 2027 or 2028 as a plausible arrival date. He also cautioned that ETA is the part of his evaluations he spends the least time on. Projecting a player’s tools is difficult enough, and promotions depend on more than talent and performance.

For the Red Sox, a possible Story-and-Arias shortstop situation is a good problem to have, Gawlowski said. In the cynical reading, keeping Story in the picture could delay Arias’s service-time clock. If Story is healthy and plays well at short, that works; if not, the player the team really wants there should be close to ready.

Honkus Wagner asked whether Walcott had logged enough shortstop work in the AFL to settle doubts about his defense, and raised the question of how Texas would manage Jung and Seager next season. Gawlowski reframed the issue: Walcott will need to keep proving he can play shortstop throughout his career.

Scouting, data, and the limits of projection

Alex Remington pointed to the Mets’ decision to hire more scouts and asked why so many teams had cut their scouting staffs, and whether this World Series matchup might prompt clubs to rebuild them. Gawlowski cited several causes: some people believe the data is sufficient without scouts; some leaders dislike the different perspective scouts bring; and some scouts, he said, don’t help their own case.

Looking back at players he rated too highly, Gawlowski said there were understandable reasons behind many projections that fell short. The mistakes that bother him most are cases where data misled him: putting too much weight on exit velocity from metal bats, for instance, or overrating a fastball because of its shape with a minor-league ball. Asked specifically about Dylan Beavers, he said readers could generally trace his reasoning through the original writeup.

And yet the data can reveal things scouts didn’t expect. Asked whether anything could be read into the 2026 draft class yet, Gawlowski said there were only scattered clues. A couple of scouts thought Ace Reece looked more hitterish than expected. So far, though, there wasn’t enough to declare that a team had botched its draft.

InsertWittyNameHere asked whether Gawlowski had seen Aidan Miller in the AFL after Keith Law reported that Miller looked good. He hadn’t; he kept missing Miller, though he thought Eric had seen him a couple of times and suggested asking Eric instead.

On the minor-league ball that produced more offense this year, maximus74 asked whether the league might overcorrect. Gawlowski wasn’t sure. His guess was that the ball would move back toward its previous state, but he noted that the league hasn’t been good at producing consistent baseballs.

There’s a similar uncertainty around relief projections. beanbong asked whether the heavy postseason use of relievers should change the future-value grades for pitchers projected as late-inning arms, citing Cade Smith, who ran out of gas but threw more innings than any Cleveland pitcher other than Messick and Williams. Gawlowski called it an interesting question and said relievers are among the hardest players to project. Top relief prospects don’t reliably become dominant closers; meanwhile, it would have been difficult to foresee Smith cutting his walk rate in half as soon as he reached the majors.

In practice, Gawlowski said, he’s increasingly projecting minor-league starters as relievers while assigning them higher future-value grades than he might have a few years ago.

Roster questions and a day at the ballpark

Charles Bengal Tiger asked how the backfields work for visitors. Teams typically divide their minor leaguers into four or five squads, which play on fields usually near the stadium. There are exceptions: the Athletics, Giants, Reds, and Guardians may have backfields farther away. Often, though not always, two games run at once, usually involving either the A and A+ teams or the AA and AAA teams. A few fans attend, alongside more scouts, family members, and autograph seekers. Gawlowski’s verdict: it’s a good time.

Pirates Hurdles asked why Derek Curiel, coming from LSU, didn’t play in the minors this year, and whether he should have gone straight to A or A+. The questioner compared the decision with Murf Gray’s path. Gawlowski said it’s fairly typical for first-round picks not to reach A ball at the end of the year; some do and some don’t, and he wouldn’t read too much into it.

For a dynasty league’s winter 1.01 pick, Gawlowski named PCA, Witt, Elly, or Caminero, depending on risk tolerance and positional scarcity. He added that he isn’t a fantasy player.

Asked who would start in the Colorado Rockies’ outfield on Opening Day 2027—whenever that happens—he answered: Carrigg.

Finally, higginsford asked whether Gawlowski was glued to Peacock for the unusually early NBA opening-day tipoff. The excerpt ends before he answers.

Prospects, projections and the value of uncertainty

The clearest lesson from this exchange is that prospect rankings are forecasts, not guarantees. Brendan Gawlowski said he’d given Ezequiel Tovar a high grade; after Tovar’s 3.5-win 2024 season, Gawlowski would have been stunned to hear that two years later his walk and strikeout numbers would improve while his wRC+ fell to 55. He attributed the collapse to an approach that opponents exploited. Even a strong track record can turn quickly. That uncertainty is also why Gawlowski expects five to 10 players near the back of the top 100 to rise on next year’s list. He singled out Kilby and Luis Hernandez, and suggested Michael Arroyo could move ahead of Felnin Celesten after getting some big-league time and playing well. Kilby’s highest ceiling, in his view, is a .300 hitter with some power and above-average defense at shortstop. That’s a substantial outcome, though the exchange doesn’t pin down how likely it is. Jake Cook’s first professional season drew a more modest assessment: it was okay, with his speed looking better on the bases than it had in college. Gawlowski put Cook’s trajectory flat or slightly down. The contrast is useful. A small positive sign doesn’t necessarily change the overall projection.

Scouting means balancing the obvious with the unlikely

Amateur scouting departments appear to do both: devote serious attention to top picks while continuing to search for later-round value. Gawlowski said multiple decision-makers may personally see and speak with players expected to receive seven-figure bonuses, while other scouts keep looking for overlooked talent. If you’re wondering whether teams concentrate everything on the top 75 picks, the answer here is no; the high-profile prospects get extra attention, but the search extends beyond them. The conversation also raised a harder roster question: in a seven-game playoff series, would you rather have a lights-out reliever such as Ashby or a No. 3 starter with a 4.00 FIP? Gawlowski’s reply was a useful complication: the No. 3 starter might be the same pitcher serving as the fireman reliever. That doesn’t resolve how teams should value those roles on opening day, but it points to the limits of treating “starter” and “reliever” as fixed categories in a projection.

Roster questions, with no tidy answers

On Colorado’s outfield, Gawlowski said he’d misread a question about Cole Carigg as one about center field. He assumed the Rockies would bring back Jake McCarthy and Mickey Moniak in the corners, while conceding it was a boring answer. The exchange leaves open whether Carigg could handle the ground those spots require. And one brief opinion on basketball got a brief explanation: Gawlowski dislikes the sport because block, charge and no-call decisions feel like “just a vibe.” It’s a sharp aside, but the baseball discussion offers a more durable takeaway: projections depend on both what scouts can see and what opponents may expose later. That’s why the same chat can hold a confident ceiling for Kilby, a tentative outlook for Cook and a reminder that even a highly regarded prospect can miss.