Basketball

Reds Prospect Luke Holman Shows a Deep Arsenal After Tommy John Surgery

Oct 21, 2026 • 5 min read • views
John E. Sokolowski-Imagn Images

A strong AFL return, with a workload question ahead

Luke Holman’s Arizona Fall League results have made him one of the Peoria Desert Dogs’ most effective starters so far. The Cincinnati Reds right-hander has given up one run in nine innings across three outings, striking out 15 while allowing four hits and one walk. His latest start, against a Scottsdale Scorpions lineup featuring prospects Zyhir Hope, Bryce Rainer and Nathan Flewelling, was his cleanest yet: four scoreless innings on 52 pitches.

That performance shows what Holman can do in a short stint. The more revealing test will come when he has to work deeper into games and face hitters a second and third time. FanGraphs prospect analyst Eric Longenhagen sees a possible back-of-the-rotation starter, while waiting to see how Holman’s command and stamina hold up over six innings.

“He looks good,” Longenhagen said. He cited glove-side fastball command at 92–94 mph and a plus curveball at 78–82 mph. Holman also uses fastballs and mid-80s cutter-sliders inside against left-handed hitters, then follows with curveballs below the strike zone. Longenhagen said he wants to track Holman’s arm strength as he builds toward a full-season routine.

Health has interrupted his first professional seasons

The Reds selected Holman 71st overall in 2024, out of Louisiana State University, where he shared a rotation with Kade Anderson and Gage Jump. His first professional season barely got started. After two effective appearances in April 2025, an elbow injury led to Tommy John surgery and ended his year. A separate groin issue then limited him to four appearances in the Arizona Complex League this season.

Holman said the Reds wanted him fully healthy before he returned to competition and prepared for the Fall League. The groin was the problem, he said, while his arm felt better than ever. That distinction matters: the AFL is giving him a chance to rebuild innings after surgery, though the small sample so far can’t answer how his stuff will carry through a full workload.

Holman’s first Fall League outing came on October 5 against the Salt River Rafters. He allowed his only run of the AFL season in two innings. Since then, his fastball and breaking pitches have offered encouraging signs compared with his pre-surgery form.

The curveball leads, but the mix needs to develop

Holman said his fastball’s minimum velocity has risen since surgery, and he hopes that trend continues. His curveball, which he considers back to its previous level, remains his signature offering. He also throws a splitter, a pitch he adopted after struggling to find a reliable changeup, and a gyro-style slider that still needs refinement.

“I needed something that goes away from a lefty,” he said of the splitter. It can move unpredictably, Holman added, but he considers it a true splitter and an effective option. His account points to a developing four-pitch mix, with the slider the least settled after surgery.

The curveball’s shape gives it a distinct role. Longenhagen previously described it as a large, high-arcing pitch that appears headed well outside before bending back into the strike zone. Holman said he has thrown it since childhood and learned to pair it with the ride on his fastball. He thinks of its break as almost straight down.

That movement can turn a high curve into a useful strike. Batters may hold off when it begins above the zone, only for the pitch to dive over the plate. Once Holman establishes that he can land it, he can use the same look to tempt hitters into chasing a curve in the dirt.

Holman isn’t a high-velocity pitcher, which puts added weight on the quality and command of his secondary pitches. He said he wants to keep using the curveball while building consistency with the slider and throwing all four pitches for strikes. His immediate task is straightforward: turn these sharp short outings into durable innings, with the curveball anchoring a more dependable mix.

Holman is ranked 17th in the Cincinnati system with a 40 FV. The Fall League has supplied a promising first look after two disrupted seasons; his next step is showing that the command and stuff remain intact as his workload grows.

Source