San Diego’s path back to the postseason runs through a rotation that may need several new starters. The Padres enter the 2027 offseason with a strong position-player core and a bullpen that should remain serviceable, but departures, option decisions and workload questions leave the starting staff short on dependable innings.
A strong finish, then a rotation gap
The Padres split their first 96 games in 2026, then surged to a 43-23 second half and claimed the National League’s top Wild Card spot. They swept past the Cubs before the Brewers ended their run. That finish keeps the postseason standard in place for 2027, while the roster’s most pressing weakness remains familiar.
Walker Buehler, Robbie Ray and Casey Mize are free agents. Griffin Canning and Lucas Giolito also appear likely to reach the market: both have mutual options, a structure that rarely results in both sides agreeing to continue. Michael King is expected to opt out, while San Diego must decide whether to exercise Nick Pivetta’s $14 million club option.
If those expected exits occur, the projected rotation includes Joe Musgrove, Randy Vásquez, JP Sears and Jhony Brito. That group comes with significant uncertainty. Musgrove missed both the 2025 and 2026 seasons while recovering from Tommy John surgery. He returned for three postseason innings, but a full starter’s workload next year may be too much to expect; president of baseball operations A.J. Preller has acknowledged the concern.
Vásquez posted a respectable ERA, though his 14.8% strikeout rate was among the lowest for pitchers who logged at least 140 innings. Sears spent most of 2026 in Triple-A and recorded a 7.49 ERA there. Brito’s 2.97 ERA came with a 16.2% strikeout rate, and he also spent much of the season in the minors. San Diego needs more than a depth signing or two to make this rotation look dependable.
Payroll commitments shape the choices
The club’s books show both the strength and constraint of its long-term plan. San Diego has $180.1 million committed for 2027 and $1.0271 billion in total future obligations. Manny Machado is owed $280 million through 2033, including $35 million in signing bonus still due. Fernando Tatis Jr. has $266 million remaining through 2034; Xander Bogaerts, $175 million through 2033; and Jackson Merrill, $135 million through 2034, including $6 million in unpaid signing bonus.
Other notable guarantees include King at $66 million through 2028, Jake Cronenworth at $48 million through 2030, Musgrove at $20 million through 2027, Yuki Matsui at $13.5 million through 2028, and Sung-Mun Song at $12 million through 2029. Matsui can opt out after 2026 or 2027; Song has an opt-out after 2028. Wandy Peralta holds a $4.45 million player option for 2027.
Several more decisions could change the roster and the cost of filling it. King’s contract includes a $28 million player option with a $5 million buyout, followed by a $30 million player option for 2028. Pivetta’s deal has an $18 million player option for 2028. Miguel Andujar has an $8 million mutual option with a $2.9 million buyout; Giolito’s is $8 million with a $1.5 million buyout; and Canning’s is $5 million with a $1.8 million buyout. Kyle Hart’s $2.5 million club option carries a $200,000 buyout. A $750,000 buyout on Germán Márquez’s 2027 mutual option is also due.
Position players and free agents
The lineup should retain much of its core, though the position-player group will turn over in places. San Diego’s arbitration cases include Mason Miller, projected at $8.1 million, and Gavin Sheets at $6.5 million. The other projections are $2.8 million for JP Sears, $2.6 million for Freddy Fermin, $1.7 million for Luis Campusano, $1.3 million for Jeremiah Estrada, and $800,000 apiece for Bryan Hoeing and Jhony Brito. Hoeing and Sears are listed as possible non-tender candidates.
The free-agent group also includes Ramon Laureano, Ty France, Luis Rengifo, Austin Hays, Jason Adam and Adrián Morejón, alongside the departing pitchers. Those decisions could affect the outfield, infield and bullpen, but the rotation remains the clearest roster need.
How much room will San Diego have?
The front office’s available resources are an open question. Payroll climbed under Peter Seidler and peaked in 2023; after his death, the club pulled back. The resulting choices included trading Juan Soto to the Yankees to reduce costs and add rotation depth, while other deals drew down the farm system.
San Diego has continued to add veteran talent using structures that shift money across seasons. The Pivetta and King contracts include backloaded salaries and opt-outs; the Márquez, Canning and Giolito agreements use mutual-option buyouts to defer some payments. Those mechanisms can help shape annual payroll, but they don’t solve the immediate roster math: the Padres need multiple starters, and their capacity to acquire them will depend on the resources the front office can put behind the search.
Unlock Subscriber-Exclusive Articles Like This One With a Trade Rumors Front Office Subscription
- Access weekly subscriber-only articles by Tim Dierkes, Steve Adams, and Anthony Franco.
- Join exclusive weekly live chats with Anthony.
- Remove ads and support our writers.
- Access GM-caliber tools like our MLB Contract Tracker