Three center fielders finished at the top of baseball’s defensive rankings, and each has a credible claim to the best season. Pete Crow-Armstrong led MLB’s Fielding Run Value measure, Ceddanne Rafaela topped Defensive Runs Saved, and Andy Pages ranked first in Runs Effectively Defended. The spread says as much about the different skills these metrics reward as it does about how close the race was.
Crow-Armstrong may be the popular pick. His range produced spectacular catches and leading marks in several measures. But a closer look at throwing and smaller fielding plays helps explain why the statistical verdict isn’t unanimous. Rafaela paired strong range with especially valuable throws, while Pages made up ground with an unusually high assist total.
Three measures, three leaders
The Fielding Bible Awards were due to be announced Thursday, October 22. For the 21st annual awards, the center-field race presented an unusual challenge: public enthusiasm pointed strongly toward Crow-Armstrong, while three leading defensive measures each favored a different player.
| Crow-Amstrong | Rafaela | Pages | |
| Defensive Runs Saved | 3rd | 1st | 2nd |
| Fielding Run Value | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
| Runs Effectively Defended | 2nd | 3rd | 1st |
That ranking comes from three distinct systems: Defensive Runs Saved (DRS), created by Sports Info Solutions; MLB’s Fielding Run Value; and Chris Dial’s Runs Effectively Defended (RED), a component of the Sabermetric Defensive Index used in Gold Glove voting. Each player placed first, second and third once. The result is a tight race, not a clear statistical consensus.
Crow-Armstrong’s range sets the pace
The case for Pete Crow-Armstrong begins with how much ground he covers. He led center fielders in DRS Range Runs, Outs Above Average and RED’s range component. His outfield jump numbers were also the best in MLB, and his season included a steady run of eye-catching catches.
His 18 Range Runs Saved were the most by a center fielder since Harrison Bader also recorded 18 in 2021. That season marked the first year DRS accounted for outfielders’ pre-pitch positioning. Crow-Armstrong’s total is an elite mark, though comparisons with past Fielding Bible winners Kevin Kiermaier, Kevin Pillar and Byron Buxton suggest that kind of range has precedent.
His arm, however, didn’t add to his DRS total, a result that differs from other metrics. Sports Info Solutions calculates Outfield Arm Runs Saved from outcomes: throwing out a runner carries substantial value, while holding runners to limited advancement earns a smaller amount. Position matters, too. A hold or out recorded after fielding the ball at medium depth is worth more than the same result from a shallower position.
Runners advanced against Crow-Armstrong 52% of the time, five percentage points below the MLB average. But he recorded five assists, including two without help from a cutoff man. Both Ceddanne Rafaela and Andy Pages had more.
DRS also includes Good Fielding Plays and Defensive Misplays. Sports Info Solutions tracks about 30 types of positive plays and 60 kinds of misplays and errors, assigning fractional run values under rules originally designed by Bill James. For an outfielder, a good play might mean cutting off a hit before the batter can take an extra base. A misplay might include mishandling a ball or throwing past a cutoff man.
Those details affected the standings. Crow-Armstrong lost two Runs Saved through these ratings, while Pages gained three; Rafaela finished at zero. Crow-Armstrong had eight misplays on hits that cost his team a chance at an out or allowed a runner to take a base, plus six wasted throws after a hit, error or sacrifice fly. Rafaela had eight such plays combined; Pages had four. These moments are easy to miss in a highlight reel, but they carry weight in DRS.
Rafaela combines range and arm value
Rafaela’s strongest argument is balance. His range value trails Crow-Armstrong’s, and his arm value sits below Pages’ in some comparisons, but his combination of the two leads the DRS assessment.
He won the Fielding Bible Award the previous year with 20 Runs Saved, compared with Crow-Armstrong’s 15. Rafaela led DRS again this season through a similar mix: he made more plays than expected on shallow and medium-depth fly balls, held his own on deeper balls and added value with his throws.
Only 44% of runners advanced against him, the lowest rate for a center fielder; the MLB average was 57%. He led American League center fielders with eight assists, the third-highest total overall. Six came without a cutoff man’s help. That matched his eight assists from the prior season.
Fielding Run Value assigns less arm value to Rafaela than DRS does, reflecting a difference in how the systems evaluate defense. Statcast measures also place him among the best center fielders for jumps and arm strength. Taken together, the numbers support a strong case even for voters who favor a different model.
Pages turns chances into outs
Pages has a case that can be harder to make from a distance: his range ranks fifth in the DRS range component, well behind Crow-Armstrong’s, but his throwing arm helps close the gap. Runners advanced against Pages 54% of the time, a higher rate than against either rival. Yet he recorded 14 outfield assists—six more than Rafaela and nine more than Crow-Armstrong.
Opponents challenged Pages more often, a pattern that points to a difference between his reputation and those of the other two. Some of those attempts became outs. An assist has two kinds of value: it records an out and removes a runner from the bases. Enough successful throws can quickly lift a player in a measure such as DRS.
Pages finished first in RED and second in DRS, making him a serious contender alongside Rafaela and Crow-Armstrong. His World Series-saving catch in Game 7 the previous year helped keep attention on his defense, but the case for his season rests on the full body of work, especially his assists.
A close vote reflects different strengths
The analyst behind this assessment voted for Rafaela, citing confidence in the DRS results, while acknowledging that a vote for Crow-Armstrong or Pages would also be reasonable. That seems the right frame for the race. Crow-Armstrong supplied the most striking range; Rafaela combined range and arm value; Pages converted throws into outs at a remarkable rate.
The numbers don’t make the three seasons interchangeable. They show why a single ranking can’t capture every part of center-field defense. Crow-Armstrong could reasonably be called the top performer, but the case depends on how much weight a voter gives to range compared with throws and smaller fielding plays. All three earned the description “great”; the award will choose one winner.
Mark Simon is the head of editorial for Sports Info Solutions. SIS created Defensive Runs Saved, which has evaluated players back to 2003, and originated The Fielding Bible Awards, which have recognized defensive excellence since 2006.
The post Who’s the Best Defensive Center Fielder in Baseball? appeared first on Baseball Prospectus.