Brazil’s runoff on Sunday, October 25, is being framed as a choice between President Lula and Senator Flávio Bolsonaro. The country is split almost evenly, and the stakes reach beyond the presidency: a bill backed by Bolsonaro could change who controls the land around Brazil’s beaches. That matters because public access can disappear even when the sand and sea remain public.
The beach bill and its political champion
Flávio Bolsonaro is the son of former president Jair Bolsonaro, who is serving a sentence of more than 27 years after Brazil’s Supreme Court convicted him of plotting a coup. Flávio has also faced scrutiny over his ties to Daniel Vorcaro, the banker at the center of a major financial and political scandal. After Vorcaro’s Banco Master was placed into extrajudicial liquidation in November 2025, allegations emerged of fraud worth billions of dollars. Leaked WhatsApp messages reported by Brazilian news outlets show Flávio calling Vorcaro his “brother.” Flávio says their relationship was strictly commercial and private, despite reports that he sought millions of dollars to finance Dark Horse, a biopic about his father.
His environmental and coastal policies add to the concern. Flávio has promised to loosen rules protecting the Amazon, home to extraordinary biodiversity, and is the Senate’s leading supporter of PEC 3/2022, widely called “PEC das Praias.” Supporters say the proposal would provide occupants with legal certainty and promote tourism. Critics see a path toward privatizing Brazil’s coastline.
The bill would end federal ownership of terrenos de marinha: coastal land within 33 meters of the average high-tide line as measured in 1831. The text would leave beaches and the sea public. But the surrounding land could pass into private hands, giving owners the ability to limit access with fences or guards. That distinction sounds narrow on paper. In practice, control of the land around a beach can determine whether people can reach it.
A dispute over an island
Here’s the thing: the debate over “legal certainty” lands differently when set beside allegations involving a wealthy and politically connected figure. This summer, Brazilian footballer Richarlison de Andrade—whose bicycle kick won FIFA’s 2022 World Cup goal award—said Flávio Bolsonaro and a lawyer friend took a mansion and private island near Angra dos Reis after he had invested about R$10 million, or roughly US$2 million.
View this post on Instagram
Richarlison says he turned down several offers for the island, including one from Flávio. He and his investors were told that transferring the title into his name could take months or even years because ownership was complicated. Yet, according to Richarlison, Flávio’s lawyer friend Willer Tomaz obtained ownership within 24 hours. The title is now held by a company linked to Tomaz, and Richarlison says he was never paid.
Flávio says he acted only as a witness. Tomaz says the courts ruled in his favor, and Brazil’s Federal Police have been asked to investigate. The claims remain contested, and the available account doesn’t settle the legal questions. Still, the reported speed of the transfer, set against the delays Richarlison says he was quoted, deserves scrutiny.
View this post on Instagram
Whatever investigators or courts conclude, the episode sharpens the irony in Flávio’s support for a bill that promises “legal certainty to occupants.” If Richarlison’s account is accurate, certainty depended heavily on who had access to legal and political power. The proposed law could apply that same principle across vast stretches of coastline.
Public access can erode gradually
Other places show what can happen when private control shapes access to beaches. Hawaii and California protect public access in law. Along parts of the US East Coast, beachgoers and surfers must buy passes. And a recent NPR/WBUR report said fewer than 1% of Jamaica’s beaches are freely accessible to the public, leaving many locals shut out of their own coastline.
Access rarely disappears all at once. Paid seasonal passes can become year-round fees; parking can be removed; each change makes a beach harder to reach. If you’re weighing what’s at stake in Brazil’s vote, the key question is what happens to the land that connects the public to the shore. The video below, which the source describes as AI-generated, sets out the issues in the election.
View this post on Instagram
Brazil’s beaches are part of its surfing edge
Brazil’s rise in professional surfing is tied to the culture that produced it. Gabriel Medina’s 2014 world title helped launch the Brazilian Storm, and restricting access to beaches could weaken the scene that followed. It’s impossible to say whether privatization would lead to fewer world titles, but the risk is clear: fewer open beaches could mean fewer chances for surfers to develop. The beaches matter beyond competition. Rio’s shoreline is known for its beauty and the way it brings people together. Turn that public space into a resort-style enclave, and it could lose the character that makes it distinctive. That’s a bigger cost than a change in beach access; it could erode part of what made Brazilian surfing resonate worldwide.Related: A Drug Smuggler Founded Pavones. Now The ‘Utopia’ Is Fighting for Its Life.