Basketball

FanGraphs ALCS Live Chat Connects Baseball Fans Beyond the Game

Oct 16, 2026 • 5 min read • views

The most revealing part of this ALCS thread may be what happens when the game stops: fans turn a rain delay into a conversation about playoff odds, job hunting, coding, and a cat that has claimed someone’s lap. That’s the appeal of a live member chat. The baseball gives everyone a reason to show up; the community supplies the rest.

FanGraphs says the Open Game Thread is for Members only, and posts appear immediately, unlike messages in its usual staff Q&A chats. The site describes its community as thousands of knowledgeable baseball fans and says staff may join in. It also asks Members to be courteous, warning that disruptive users could lose chat privileges.

Seven games, if the teams can get there

millvillemeltdown — 7:44 PM: A nearby Brewers fan doesn’t care which team wins the series, as long as it lasts seven games. millvillemeltdown thinks that’s a fair position.

turfe — 7:47 PM: Wouldn’t a seven-game series cost Milwaukee some momentum?

millvillemeltdown — 7:50 PM: How big is Milwaukee, anyway? The city’s collective inertia ought to carry the team for a while.

Sean Dolinar — 7:54 PM: A seven-game series, with two extra-inning games in TBR.

Sean Dolinar — 7:55 PM: There are two off days between a Game 7 and Game 1 of the World Series. That should give a bullpen plenty of time to recover, though the starting-pitcher rotation might not line up.

Sean Dolinar — 7:47 PM: More baseball would be fine by him.

The appetite for a long series is easy to understand. The harder question is what it would do to the teams advancing: Sean sees enough time for relievers to recover, but flags the starting-pitcher schedule as a possible complication.

A baseball job, and the skills it might take

drplantwrench — 7:55 PM: Without sharing too much, they got an interview in baseball after spotting a job posting on FanGraphs, and thanked the site.

millvillemeltdown — 7:55 PM: Congratulations.

Sean Dolinar — 7:56 PM: That’s great news, and he wished them luck.

turfe — 7:56 PM: Congratulations, too.

Sean Dolinar — 7:56 PM: Did the applicant have to get through AI-written resumes and AI screening by HR?

millvillemeltdown — 7:56 PM: They’d rather not think about the ordeal waiting after their thermodynamics midterm.

drplantwrench — 7:58 PM: So far, the application and interview process has been pretty lightweight.

Sean Dolinar — 8:01 PM: He’d be scared to apply for jobs again.

That job conversation quickly turns toward technical skills. millvillemeltdown — 8:09 PM: Their classmates keep complaining about R. They’ve never used it, keep seeing advice to learn it and “upskill,” and don’t want to.

millvillemeltdown — 8:10 PM: They already spend enough time wrestling with computers and don’t want to wrestle a computer so it can wrestle more computers.

Alan Sherman — 8:12 PM: More than 15 years ago, he had college classmates learning R. If the language is still in use after that much time—an eternity in computing—it may be a better investment than learning some alternatives.

millvillemeltdown — 8:15 PM: They’ll admit they don’t enjoy statistics. Learning R might help, but taking quantum mechanics for that reason last year wasn’t pleasant.

mlommler — 8:15 PM: Learning R in graduate school, along with non-coding skills, has kept them steadily employed since 2021.

drplantwrench — 8:15 PM: They’re in a similar position, but chose Python instead of R.

mlommler — 8:16 PM: They’ve been gradually building their Python skills, mainly for ArcGIS.

Sean Dolinar — 8:17 PM: He’s keen to turn the thread into a coding chat.

mlommler — 8:17 PM: Until baseball resumes?

drplantwrench — 8:18 PM: They ask whether the chat is built mostly with JavaScript.

Alan Sherman — 8:18 PM: If the conversation becomes about coding, will he need to leave, or might he learn something?

drplantwrench — 8:19 PM: Probably neither: the discussion may be hard to follow and boring, with an occasional dumb joke.

Alan Sherman — 8:19 PM: He jokes that Sean must have made a custom programming language just for FanGraphs.

Rain delay, with pizza and a cat

Sean Dolinar — 8:02 PM: The weather in Cleveland looks wet. The tarp has just gone back on the field, which is bad news.

Anonymous Member #46 — 8:03 PM: Tarps on the field and baseball in 2026 don’t belong together.

Anonymous Member #46 — 8:04 PM: They sat down on the couch without realizing the game would be delayed. Now a sleeping cat is on their lap, and their book is in another room.

Sean Dolinar — 8:13 PM: He’s checked Cleveland’s weather more in the past week than ever before.

drplantwrench — 8:15 PM: Mike Trout would be disappointed in him.

Sean Dolinar — 8:15 PM: He checks the weather often, just not Cleveland’s.

Sean Dolinar — 8:16 PM: He checks sunrise and sunset, too.

Alan Sherman — 8:15 PM: Living on the other side of Lake Erie, he says storms generally come from Cleveland’s direction.

The delay also gives Michael Minetti a chance to revisit the season’s betting choices. Michael Minetti — 8:01 PM: He backed the Rays at 25/1 to win the AL East, crediting FanGraphs projections for the bet, and has followed them all year. He likes Tampa Bay at +155 to win the World Series, but the Sim says he needs 2/1, so he’ll pass.

Sean Dolinar — 8:05 PM: Betting against the Brewers because of FanGraphs projections would have cost him money.

Michael Minetti — 8:07 PM: He says he’s lost money betting against Milwaukee for three straight years.

Sean Dolinar — 8:08 PM: He apologizes.

Michael Minetti — 8:10 PM: He did pick the two long-shot AL East winners, Toronto and Tampa Bay, thanks to FanGraphs. That has made up for many over/under misses.

Keaton Arneson — 8:20 PM: The worst is settling onto the couch with delivered pizza, then seeing a tarp on the field.

Anonymous Member #46 — 8:21 PM: At least Keaton has pizza. They have a cat.

mlommler — 8:21 PM: Spare a thought for the people who see the tarp without pizza.

Under the hood: a familiar mix of tools

FanGraphs’ chat runs on a split stack: Next.js, React and JavaScript on the front end, with .NET and C# powering the back end. Some older site pages still use .NET Web Forms. That mix will sound familiar to anyone who’s worked inside a company where newer tools sit alongside older systems. Sean Dolinar says he’d like to use more Python, though he doesn’t work closely with the site’s ETL process. The chat’s win polls have also become more realistic: Keaton Arneson recalled that Game 1 had put the Rays at 91%. The code talk quickly turned into a friendly Python-versus-R debate, with one reader declaring allegiance to R and another insisting Python was better. The more useful point came from a field biologist in the chat: you don’t need to know every corner of a language to solve problems. Learn the basics, then use documentation and places like Stack Overflow when the work gets thorny. Fair advice, especially for readers who admitted they understood only some of the coding jargon.

Readers have a wishlist for the site

The clearest product ideas were about making FanGraphs more interactive. One reader proposed charts for leaderboards, with hover text and filters for splits. That could help readers explore the numbers without leaving the tables they already use. The idea came with a caveat: the chat didn’t specify which visuals would be most useful, and the value would depend on how well they fit the data. Readers also asked for comment notifications, including alerts when someone replies or likes a joke. Dolinar said email notifications should be straightforward and app alerts might be possible. He floated a bigger change, too: replacing WordPress comments with a modified version of chat. That’s a much broader product decision, but the underlying request is simple—make it easier to follow conversations. Custom baseball emojis came up as another small feature with a clear audience. Arneson said he regularly uses an Austin Hedges photo emoji in a group chat, joking that Hedges’ league average hitting line this year—wRC+ 😉—helped make it popular. Dolinar said the chat can already use PNG images, though each one has to be added in code. Between the feature requests, the chat drifted into baseball jokes, a storm near Cleveland and the feeding schedules of several tabby cats. One 15-year-old cat caught a fly; another was already waiting for dinner 90 minutes early. The thread’s mix of software talk and ordinary baseball-chat digressions is part of the point: readers want tools that make these conversations easier to keep going.

By the late innings, this Fangraphs game thread had become a grab bag: a reader shared a questionnaire said to have been used by a baseball team for job screening, and floated a few chat-feature requests, including image uploads and the ability to delete your own comments. The link was posted with a quick check that it was allowed: the questionnaire.

Baseball barely held the conversation together. One reader joked that their knowledge of the chat’s topics had a .000/.000/.000 slash line; host Sean Dolinar replied that this was why he wasn’t often invited. The detours ranged from coding and 1908 references to cats pinning people to couches, Cleveland weather, and beer: an Edmund Fitzgerald Porter sounded good in Great Lakes weather, while Dolinar recalled drinking Railbender in Erie. Another commenter warned that feeding a cat three meals a day can be a habit that’s painful to undo.

Then the thread ran out of time. Dolinar said they’d have to continue the discussion the next day or Sunday, calling it the best “non-game game thread” they’d had. The next chat was set for the same time during Game 4, with Game 5 scheduled for Sunday at 5 p.m. ET. One last question—when had a playoff game last been rained out?—was left hanging. That loose ending suits the thread: its appeal was less the game than the odd, lively company watching it together.

Source