Basketball

Orioles Weigh Catching Upgrade Around Samuel Basallo for 2027

Oct 16, 2026 • 5 min read • views

Baltimore’s catching question for 2027 comes down to how much offense the Orioles want beside Samuel Basallo. The club has three catchers on its 40-man roster, but Roch Kubatko of MASNsports.com reports that Baltimore is “likely” to seek a stronger bat than Carlos Narváez or Yohel Pozo.

[RELATED: Orioles Offseason Outlook]

Basallo is the long-term bet

The Orioles’ direction looks clearer since they traded Samuel Basallo a contract covering him through 2033, with a club option for 2034. The eight-year, $67 million extension came in August 2025, just days after the 22-year-old made his major league debut. Baltimore later dealt three-time All-Star Adley Rutschman to the Red Sox at the Aug. 3 deadline, in a package that included four prospects and Narváez. Rutschman was entering his final year of team control in 2027.

Basallo’s bat showed progress after a difficult first taste of the majors. He posted a 56 wRC+ in 118 plate appearances last year, then lifted that mark to 95 this season, with a .222/.291/.406 line and 18 home runs across 399 plate appearances. That’s a reasonable platform for a young catcher, though the Orioles will want more as he settles into a regular role.

His defense presents a more mixed picture. Basallo caught 63 games, appeared 34 times at designated hitter and played first base 12 times. He threw out 26.1% of would-be base stealers, above the 22.7% league average, and ranked in the 67th percentile for pop time and 73rd for blocking. Framing remains a clear weakness: he finished in the ninth percentile, with minus-3 Fielding Run Value and minus-1.9 Runs Above Average on ABS challenges, ranking 101st among 107 catchers.

A move to first base once seemed possible for the 6-foot-4, 250-pound Basallo. That’s harder to picture soon after Baltimore committed five years and $155 million to Pete Alonso, who excelled in his first season with the club. Keeping Basallo behind the plate leaves the Orioles with reason to consider another catcher who can contribute more offensively.

Narváez and Pozo offer roster flexibility

Carlos Narváez looked like a viable offensive option as a Boston rookie in 2025, batting .241/.306/.419 with 15 homers and a 99 wRC+ in 446 plate appearances. His 2026 season was a sharp reversal: a .161/.241/.226 line, three home runs and a 33 wRC+ in 285 trips to the plate. After the trade to Baltimore, he hit just .104/.198/.117. That 33 wRC+ ranked last among 318 hitters with at least 250 plate appearances.

Yohel Pozo, claimed off waivers from St. Louis in late July, had only 62 plate appearances. He hit .250/.258/.317 with one homer and a 58 wRC+ between the Cardinals and Orioles. The 29-year-old’s career major league wRC+ is 76 over 205 plate appearances. His stronger Triple-A line—.316/.338/.536 in 1,450 plate appearances—needs context, as some of that production came in the hitter-friendly Pacific Coast League.

Both Narváez and Pozo have minor league options remaining and aren’t due for arbitration until after next season. Baltimore can keep them as depth without using a roster spot all year, which gives president of baseball operations Mike Elias room to pursue a different fit.

Free agency and trade options

Ryan Jeffers stands out among the available free-agent catchers, but a multiyear deal could be costly. He’s also likely to receive a qualifying offer, and signing a player who turns one down would cost Baltimore its third-highest selection in the 2027 draft. More attainable names with offensive credibility could include Tyler Stephenson, Carson Kelly and Kyle Higashioka, along with former Orioles James McCann and Gary Sánchez.

Trade discussions may surface around Colorado’s Hunter Goodman and Oakland’s Shea Langeliers, both power-hitting catchers. Their clubs would likely demand substantial returns. Baltimore’s decision may hinge on whether it wants a short-term offensive complement for Basallo or is prepared to pay more for a longer-term pairing. Basallo’s development gives the Orioles a foundation; the next move is finding a partner whose bat can make the position more productive.