Basketball

Phillies Face Infield Overhaul as Turner’s Defense and Roster Depth Come Into Focus

Oct 17, 2026 • 5 min read • views

Philadelphia’s infield plans for 2027 hinge on two unresolved questions: whether Trea Turner can steady his defense at shortstop, and how the Phillies will replace players who may leave in free agency. The club’s trade-deadline reshuffle around Luis Arraez didn’t provide a lasting answer, and the team’s poor defensive results give new manager Don Mattingly a clear area to address.

A short-term shuffle leaves long-term gaps

To fit Luis Arraez into the lineup at the trade deadline, Philadelphia moved Bryson Stott to third base, Alec Bohm to first, and Bryce Harper to right field. Trea Turner was the lone infielder who stayed at his usual position.

The experiment didn’t pay off. Arraez’s production fell after he joined the Phillies, and a left ankle sprain kept him off the Wild Card Series roster. Philadelphia returned Stott to second base and used Edmundo Sosa at third in its first-round loss to Atlanta.

Arraez, Bohm and Sosa are all headed for free agency. President of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski said Thursday that Harper is expected to return to first base as his primary position, with occasional outfield appearances still possible, according to Todd Zolecki of MLB.com. Dombrowski also said the club hopes to play Kyle Schwarber at first base more often, creating opportunities to rest Harper at designated hitter.

Turner’s defense is under scrutiny

Turner is slated to open 2027 at shortstop, but Dombrowski made clear that his hold on the position depends on improvement. “From a defensive perspective, we were very clear. He knows he has to be better at shortstop,” Dombrowski said, in remarks carried by The Associated Press. “I told him it’s really mandatory that it’s like that. … You cannot play shortstop like you did defensively in ’26 going to ’27.”

At 33, Turner is coming off the worst season of his career. His .242/.297/.378 batting line set career lows outside his brief 2015 rookie season. He still hit 19 home runs and scored more than 100 runs, but his place near the top of the order and 156 starts helped produce those totals. Turner was one of 14 players to reach 700 plate appearances.

The defensive numbers were more alarming. Turner committed 21 errors, tying Otto Lopez of Miami for the major league lead. His minus-17 Defensive Runs Saved ranked last among shortstops, while his minus-8 Outs Above Average was fifth-worst at the position. He cut down on mistakes late, with just one error in September, but the season’s full record has put his role in question.

Turner’s defense had already slipped in 2023 and 2024 before he rebounded in 2025. This year, he handled balls hit to his right well but struggled on plays coming toward him and on balls up the middle. His speed remains intact, and his arm has never been a major strength. The concern is consistency; if the errors persist, an in-season move to the outfield is a possibility.

Prospects offer options, but not a complete plan

Sosa was the only other Phillie to start at shortstop this season. Top prospect Aidan Miller missed nearly the entire year with back problems. Now healthy, he’s playing in the Arizona Fall League to regain some of the time he lost, and has appeared at third base there.

Bryan Rincon, 22, had a strong season in Double-A and is expected to be added to the 40-man roster this winter. Philadelphia will likely want him to face Triple-A pitching first, though a midseason call-up remains possible.

Stott is entering his final arbitration-controlled season and remains a plus defender at second base. He can cover either position on the left side of the infield, but second is his best fit. Miller could earn the everyday third-base job in spring training; even if he does, the club would still need a stronger utility option than Otto Kemp.

Philadelphia is likely to need at least one infielder from outside the organization if it doesn’t retain Bohm or Arraez. A versatile player such as Mauricio Dubón would address several needs. Free-agent alternatives include utility players Isiah Kiner-Falefa and Ha-Seong Kim. The club could also explore trades for Willi Castro or Jared Triolo.

Defense sets the offseason agenda

The infield decisions sit within a wider fielding problem. Philadelphia finished 22nd in Outs Above Average and tied the A’s for last in Defensive Runs Saved this season. Mattingly identified defense as a priority after becoming the full-time manager. “Defense is just a premium. It’s an area that I really would like to push,” he told reporters in a Zoom session this week.

That push starts with the roster decisions ahead: Turner needs to show he can handle shortstop, while the club must find dependable coverage across the infield. The prospects may help, but Philadelphia’s offseason additions will shape whether its defense can improve right away.