The Yankees’ third-base problem sits at the intersection of two needs: a more productive lineup and a payroll already under pressure. Ryan McMahon’s 2026 season gave New York little reason to count on him as an everyday answer, but replacing him could mean taking on more salary just as the club faces decisions across the roster.
That tension follows a three-game ALDS sweep by the Rays. The Yankees had a strong regular season, yet their postseason exit sharpened the case for upgrades. Third base is one of the clearest places to look: New York’s production there ranked among the league’s weakest, while McMahon’s bat and defense both slipped.
McMahon’s bat and glove both regressed
In 124 games, the 31-year-old hit .213/.279/.357, producing a 78 wRC+—22% below league average. His 29.4% strikeout rate ranked in the ninth percentile by Statcast and was almost identical to his 29.3% career mark. The bigger concern is that the rest of his offensive profile also moved in the wrong direction.
McMahon’s walk rate fell to a career-low 7.8%, leaving him with a .279 on-base percentage. After hitting at least 20 home runs in six of the previous seven seasons, he finished 2026 with 11. His .143 isolated power was below the .156 league average and the lowest of his career.
The team-level numbers underline the cost of that production. Yankees third basemen combined for a 74 wRC+, tied with the Marlins for the fifth-lowest mark in the majors. McMahon had averaged 2.3 fWAR per season from 2021 through 2025, in large part because of his defense. This year he produced 0.5 fWAR, roughly replacement level.
His defensive metrics also fell sharply. After totaling +10 Defensive Runs Saved and +7 Outs Above Average in 2025, he posted -3 DRS and 0 OAA this season. Statcast has generally credited him for covering ground to either side, but his range was closer to average in 2026.
There’s room for caution before treating one season as a permanent decline. McMahon had played at least 151 games in each season from 2021 through 2025, then missed time this year with a throat infection in late June and a left thumb sprain in late August. Those were his first injured-list stints in more than seven years, but neither injury offers an obvious explanation for the reduced range. The drop could be a one-year dip; at 31, it could also mark the beginning of an age-related slide.
The contract makes the choice harder
McMahon is guaranteed $16 million, a salary that ranks seventh on New York’s payroll. That’s a substantial commitment for a player who has never been a strong hitter and whose defensive value is now less certain. The Yankees could decide his 2026 performance makes him expendable, but clearing his salary would be only part of the calculation: they’d still need a credible replacement.
Several other roster questions compete for the same budget. Fernando Cruz, who is injured, could be a non-tender candidate. Paul Blackburn and closer David Bednar are headed for free agency, and current reports expect New York to make Bednar a qualifying offer. If Bednar stays, his cost could rise through acceptance of the offer or, more likely, a sizable multiyear agreement. The bullpen may need additional arms either way.
Jazz Chisholm Jr. is also a free agent, despite his desire to remain in New York. The Yankees have considered moving Luis Garcia Jr. to second base if Chisholm leaves. If Garcia instead stays at first, Anthony Volpe may be the next internal option at second; his own bat has been underwhelming. Those decisions could add another position and another expense to the offseason agenda.
Giancarlo Stanton’s contract further narrows the room to maneuver. He turns 37 in November and is entering the final season of the 13-year, $325 million extension he signed with the Marlins in November 2014. He is due a $25 million salary in 2027, along with a $10 million buyout attached to a club option for 2028. Miami is scheduled to contribute $20 million, leaving the Yankees responsible for $15 million of the guarantee.
After another injury-interrupted year, Stanton’s role is less straightforward with Ben Rice and Aaron Judge also candidates for designated hitter time. New York could release Stanton and absorb the remaining cost, but that would add dead money while the club is trying to address other weaknesses.
Payroll pressure constrains the alternatives
MLBTR’s Payroll Tracker puts the Yankees at a $282.1 million luxury-tax payroll for 2027, before accounting for arbitration salaries. MLBTR contributor Matt Swartz projects that arbitration-eligible players will earn $36.7 million. New York is therefore likely to approach the highest luxury-tax threshold next year. A salary cap resulting from collective bargaining negotiations would create a different pressure: the club would need to cut payroll substantially.
In either case, paying McMahon or Stanton to leave would be a difficult expense to absorb, particularly if the Yankees then spend to fill third base. That’s the central constraint. The baseball case for improving at the position is clear; the financial case depends on what New York can do elsewhere and how it values the available alternatives.
Free agency and trades offer imperfect fits
Teruaki Sato is among the leading bats available, regardless of position, and should draw significant interest. The Yankees could pursue him, but competition is likely to make him expensive. Other free-agent possibilities are less direct. Alec Bohm would be a rebound bet, while Chisholm and J.P. Crawford would be playing out of position at third.
The trade market could offer a different path. Houston’s Isaac Paredes, Minnesota’s Royce Lewis and St. Louis’ Nolan Gorman are among the candidates. The Astros hold a $13.35 million club option on Paredes; if he finishes in the top 10 of AL MVP voting, it becomes a mutual option. He is otherwise in his final season of team control, giving Houston a reason to consider a trade and redirect the savings toward its own roster. Lewis and Gorman, like Bohm, would require the acquiring team to bet on a rebound.
New York’s choice is therefore less about finding a perfect third baseman than deciding how much uncertainty it can tolerate. Keeping McMahon preserves a known salary and avoids the cost of a replacement, but it means accepting the possibility that his 2026 decline continues. Moving on could bring a better bat, yet the most appealing alternatives carry their own price, positional or performance questions.
The Yankees’ need extends beyond one position. Their offense struggled after Judge went down with a rib injury, posting a 93 wRC+ that tied for fifth-worst in the majors over that stretch. A third-base upgrade won’t solve that broader weakness by itself, but another season with so little production at the hot corner would leave the lineup short of the support it needs. New York’s decision on McMahon will show how it plans to balance that offensive need against a crowded, costly offseason.
Photo courtesy of Brad Penner, Imagn Images