Basketball

Cardinals Face a Catcher Roster Crunch as Leo Bernal Moves Into Focus

Oct 14, 2026 • 5 min read • views

St. Louis has a catching surplus, but the Cardinals’ plans for Leo Bernal make the trade conversation more specific: the club may want to keep its emerging starter while listening on three other major league catchers. Interest in the organization’s depth has persisted for more than a year, and the arrival of top prospect Rainiel Rodriguez adds another reason to consider how the position fits together.

Bernal’s opportunity narrows the field

The Cardinals have four catchers on their 40-man roster: Bernal, Iván Herrera, Jimmy Crooks and Pedro Pagés. Rodriguez, who has reached Double-A, doesn’t yet need a 40-man spot. But after hitting .328/.408/.591 there at age 19, he could reach the majors in 2027, with Triple-A and a possible 2028 promotion as the minimum near-term expectation.

Bernal is positioned to get the first opportunity. The 22-year-old, who turns 23 in February, joined the club during September roster expansion and started 22 of its final 24 games. He made 15 starts at catcher and seven at first base or designated hitter, hitting .284 with five home runs. Six errors raised questions about his defense, though scouting assessments generally project him as serviceable behind the plate.

Derrick Goold of The St. Louis Post-Dispatch reports that the Cardinals would prefer to make Bernal their primary catcher in 2027. That makes a trade less likely unless another club offers a starting pitcher with substantial upside. Rodriguez also looks difficult to pry away as St. Louis retools.

That leaves Herrera, Crooks and Pagés as the more plausible trade candidates. Each offers a different profile, and the value of a deal would depend on whether a potential buyer needs offense, a developmental chance or a dependable backup.

Herrera offers offense, with a defensive limitation

Herrera’s bat should draw attention from clubs with designated hitter at-bats to fill. His career line is .265/.362/.410 across nearly 1,500 plate appearances, and he has hit 19 home runs in each of the past two seasons. He’s especially productive against left-handed pitching, with a .260/.405/.418 career line when holding the platoon advantage.

The defensive case is harder to make. St. Louis started Herrera behind the plate 52 times, compared with 108 appearances at DH. His receiving metrics are around league average, but controlling the running game has been a persistent weakness. He ranked 79th among 94 catchers in average pop time to second base at 2.00 seconds. A long exchange and below-average throwing velocity have contributed to just one caught stealing in the past two years. His career record is eight caught stealing in 128 attempts; one additional credited out came on a pickoff throw by Matthew Liberatore that led to a rundown.

An elbow injury required postseason surgery and may have affected Herrera’s arm strength. His 2026 rate stats also dipped from his usual level, largely after a poor July. Still, clubs seeking a right-handed hitter with value against lefties may accept limited catching work.

Herrera has three years of team control remaining and is entering arbitration. MLB Trade Rumors contributor Matt Swartz projects a 2027 salary around $5.5 million. The Blue Jays, Mariners, Mets, Twins, Braves, Diamondbacks and Pirates could have reason to consider him, given their struggles against left-handed pitching or need for more DH production.

Crooks may need a new team to get a real audition

Crooks has the clearest chance among the three trade candidates to develop into a regular, all-around catcher, but his major league results have been poor so far. The left-handed hitter has a .168/.231/.313 line in 195 plate appearances. At 25, he’s also been passed on the Cardinals’ depth chart by the younger Bernal, making another organization a plausible place for him to compete for a sustained opportunity.

His minor league record gives scouts a reason to look beyond that major league sample. Baseball America ranked him among St. Louis’ top 10 prospects in both 2025 and 2026, and FanGraphs included him among its top 100 prospects in February. Crooks has hit .283/.371/.484 at Triple-A, though questions remain about his pure hitting ability. Reports have been more positive about his defense.

Two option years remain, so the Cardinals don’t face immediate roster pressure to move him. A trade could nevertheless convert a player blocked by Bernal and Rodriguez into a young pitcher. The Angels, Giants, Rangers, Phillies, Nationals and Athletics may have reason to explore the position; the Athletics’ needs could change if they trade Shea Langeliers.

Pagés fits the backup role

Pagés is the simplest evaluation: he’s a 28-year-old with a .229/.275/.354 line over parts of three seasons, paired with reliable receiving and a plus arm. He has thrown out 26% of opposing base stealers. The bat is unlikely to make him a first-division catcher, but his defense gives him a credible path as a backup or third catcher.

Pagés has two option years left and will qualify for arbitration for the first time as a Super Two player. Swartz projects his salary at about $1.3 million. St. Louis could keep him as an experienced presence for Bernal and Rodriguez, or seek a depth starter or middle reliever in return.

The Yankees, Diamondbacks, Rangers, Twins, Phillies, White Sox and Astros are among the clubs with backup catcher questions. The Cardinals have time to choose their route, but Bernal’s projected role and Rodriguez’s progress make the surplus increasingly tangible. Herrera offers the most immediate offense, Crooks the most developmental upside and Pagés the steadiest defense.