Basketball

Predators Continue Defensive Overhaul After Jayden Struble Trade

Oct 14, 2026 • 5 min read • views

Nashville’s blue-line rebuild has a clear gap: the Predators need a defender who can handle top-pairing minutes alongside Roman Josi. New general manager Chris MacFarland has made seven trades that directly affect the lineup, and the latest brought in Jayden Struble from Montreal four days ago. On yesterday’s episode of 32 Thoughts: The Podcast, insider Elliotte Friedman said Nashville plans to keep remaking its defense. Struble, he reported, was “just the first part of it.”

The defensive problem behind Nashville’s decline

The Predators’ struggles since reaching the Stanley Cup Final in 2017 are often framed as a shortage of forward talent. Their 2025-26 results point to another pressing issue: Nashville ranked 20th in offense and gave up 269 goals, the eighth-highest total in the league.

That workload has also tested goaltender Juuse Saros. He faced an average of 28 shots per game last season and, according to Moneypuck data, made the sixth-most saves on unblocked shot attempts. Saros remains well regarded, but a defense that gives opponents that many chances makes his job harder and leaves little margin for error.

Nashville once had one of the league’s strongest defensive groups, with Mattias Ekholm and Ryan Ellis supporting Josi in the top four. Those days are gone. Josi, now 36, still anchors the group, but the minutes he has carried through the team’s difficult seasons make it harder to treat him as the solution to every defensive need.

The current options behind him offer uneven support. Brady Skjei hasn’t matched the level expected of a player with a $7 million average annual value. Nicolas Hague brings size, though his fit appears closer to a third-pairing role like the one he had in Vegas. Nicklaus Perbix hasn’t provided the stability he showed in Tampa and cleared waivers two weeks ago.

Young defenders Adam Wilsby and William Trudeau give Nashville pieces to develop. The club claimed Trudeau off waivers from the Rangers last month, and Hall of Famer Rob Blake is now evaluating the roster in his new role. Still, the need is evident: a top-pairing defender who can drive play and take difficult minutes off Josi’s schedule.

Possible targets come with a steep price

Carolina’s Alexander Nikishin is an intriguing fit. Nashville’s reported interest surfaced last month as the 25-year-old’s restricted free-agent situation dragged on. MacFarland’s trade of the team’s most proven young talent, Luke Evangelista, left fans questioning the return. The draft capital Nashville added could be relevant to a pursuit of Nikishin, but a report yesterday said no trade was imminent. Any talks with Carolina general manager Eric Tulsky appear to be at an early stage.

Nikishin’s age could fit a rebuilding plan. The cost and timing are less straightforward. A deal built around a contract carrying roughly a $9 million average annual value would raise the stakes: Nashville would need to improve quickly rather than spend years near the bottom of the standings as Nikishin approaches his late twenties.

Detroit’s Simon Edvinsson also matches the profile Nashville lacks, with top-pairing potential at 23. But his contract situation and apparent desire to move on make a trade hard to map out. Evangelista might have appealed to Detroit as an established young forward; Nashville instead received future draft picks for him. The Predators could offer recent first-round prospects such as Brady Martin or Tanner Molendyk, though paying from the prospect pool could solve one roster problem while creating another.

Struble strengthens the lower pair

Struble should help with the more immediate task of improving the third pairing. Montreal received a second-round pick, a return that looks substantial, but the 25-year-old brings physical play, sound gap control and strong breakout ability. Those traits could give Nashville a meaningful upgrade lower in the lineup even if he isn’t the top-four answer the roster still needs.

The Predators face Vegas tonight, with their defense under close watch as they deploy seven defensemen. Jack Ahcan, acquired from Colorado, made the team out of camp somewhat unexpectedly. At 5 feet 8 inches, the 29-year-old is an exceptionally mobile left-shot defender with a strong AHL record. His style recalls what Nashville lost when it traded Nick Blankenburg to Colorado in March—a deal that sent him to MacFarland’s former club.

Ahcan and Struble can help round out the group, and that matters. But the central question for MacFarland and Blake remains whether they can add a defender who makes the top four stronger and reduces Josi’s burden. Until they do, Nashville’s defensive makeover will remain unfinished.

Image Credit: James Guillory-Imagn Images via Reuters Connect